American Medical International v. Feller: The 1976 “Fairness” Case Superseded by Statute

American Medical International v. Feller (1976) applied the old partition statute. Its "fairness" limit is not the law under CCP 872.710.

In American Medical International v. Feller, a 1976 case decided under the former partition statute, the Court of Appeal denied a 98.75 percent owner's partition of a Los Angeles hospital because of an implied waiver tied to a 20-year lease; its "requirement of fairness" is not the law under CCP 872.710.

Co-owners who want to stop a partition sometimes argue that a court can deny partition because a sale would be unfair to them. That argument is without merit. It comes from American Medical International, Inc. v. Feller (1976) 59 Cal.App.3d 1008 (“AMI”), a Court of Appeal decision that applied California’s old partition statute, which the Legislature replaced that same year. Today, Code of Civil Procedure section 872.710 provides that partition of co-owned property “shall be as of right unless barred by a valid waiver.” There is no fairness exception.

AMI has been superseded by statute on this point. Its “requirement of fairness” does not represent the current state of California law, which gives every co-owner an absolute right to partition unless a valid waiver bars it.

Why American Medical International v. Feller Matters

  1. It was decided under the old law. The court said the right to partition “is governed by statute” and cited former Code of Civil Procedure section 752, the statute the 1976 Partition Law replaced. (AMI, at p. 1013.)
  2. Its fairness rule did not survive. CCP 872.710’s right to partition recognizes one defense for co-owners: a valid waiver. The Court of Appeal has twice said AMI does not guide the analysis under that statute.
  3. Arguing fairness today is without merit. A co-owner who cites AMI to say a sale would be unfair is relying on a case decided under a statute the Legislature replaced in 1976.
  4. Only its waiver point is still repeated. Courts still cite AMI for the narrow rule that co-owners can give up partition by agreement, and even the waiver in AMI ran out when a hospital lease ended in 1980.

The Facts: Investors Bought Slivers of a Los Angeles Hospital

The property was the Westside Hospital in Los Angeles. In 1960, the hospital was in financial trouble, and its owner, Denward, Inc., put together an investment plan. Denward transferred a 50 percent interest to Bruce I. Hochman as trustee and leased the hospital for 20 years to an operating company, at $153,000 a year for the first 10 years and $132,000 a year for the next 10. Hochman then sold undivided interests of no less than one-quarter of one percent to investors, including some of the hospital’s staff doctors.

Hochman’s application to the state Commissioner of Corporations for a permit to sell those interests said: “Purchasers shall waive their statutory right to partition the realty,” except after a notice of default on the hospital’s trust deed. The deeds the investors received did not repeat the waiver, but an agreement recorded in 1960 referred to the permit.

Jack Feller and Mollie Levin bought small interests in 1960: one-half of one percent and three-quarters of one percent. By 1972, American Medical International had bought Denward’s 50 percent and another 48.75 percent from Hochman’s investors, leaving it with 98.75 percent and the two defendants with 1.25 percent. Everyone agreed the hospital could not be physically divided. American Medical International sued for partition by sale, and the trial court entered an interlocutory judgment ordering the hospital sold.

How the Court of Appeal Decided the Case

An Implied Waiver Tied to the Hospital Lease

The court found that the investors “were persuaded to invest on the premise that there would be a long-term lease of the real property which would assure a secure and permanent source of income to them.” (AMI, at p. 1016.) Relying on Pine v. Tiedt, an earlier case about investors in a sanitarium, it held that Denward, which created the plan, had impliedly waived partition. American Medical International stood in Denward’s shoes, because a buyer of a co-owner’s interest “simply steps into the shoes of his grantor,” as the California Supreme Court said in Middlecoff v. Cronise (1909) 155 Cal. 185, 189. (AMI, at p. 1017.) The court also held that American Medical International had notice of the waivers: actual notice of the investors’ written waiver, and constructive notice through the recorded 1960 agreement.

The “Requirement of Fairness”

The court then went beyond waiver. It said the “absolute right” to partition “is subject to certain limitations such as estoppel and similar equitable defenses” (AMI, at p. 1013), and added:

“In addition to the limitation on the right of partition derived from express and implied waiver by agreement, there is an even wider and more general limitation. This limitation subjects the right of partition to the ‘requirement of fairness.'”

American Medical International, Inc. v. Feller (1976) 59 Cal.App.3d 1008, 1015

For that phrase, the court relied on Penasquitos, Inc. v. Holladay (1972) 27 Cal.App.3d 356, another case decided under the old statute. It closed by saying the rule binding a buyer to the seller’s waiver “is based upon principles of fairness,” and that partition was barred until the 20-year hospital lease ended in 1980. (AMI, at p. 1021.)

The Result

The Court of Appeal reversed and directed the trial court to enter judgment for the defendants. (AMI, at p. 1022.) Two investors holding 1.25 percent stopped the owner of 98.75 percent from selling the hospital until the lease ran out.

Why AMI‘s “Fairness” Rule Is No Longer the Law

AMI was decided on July 13, 1976, under former section 752, which let co-owners sue for partition “according to the respective rights of the persons interested therein.” (AMI, at p. 1013.) That same year, the Legislature enacted the current California partition statutes (Statutes 1976, chapter 73). Under CCP 872.710(b), “partition as to concurrent interests in the property shall be as of right unless barred by a valid waiver.” Apart from partnership property, the statute names one defense to the right to partition: a valid waiver. It says nothing about fairness, hardship or equity.

The Court of Appeal has said so twice. In 2023, it wrote: “Because AMI does not address section 872.710, it does not guide our analysis.” (Caiozzo v. 2672 to 2674 North Beachwood Drive, LLC (Cal. Ct. App., Nov. 13, 2023, No. B322219) 2023 WL 7485496, at *6 [nonpub. opn.].) In 2018, it told the defendant in Lipscomb v. Girardi that the case “does not address Code of Civil Procedure section 872.710, which was enacted the same year that AMI was decided.” (Lipscomb v. Girardi (Cal. Ct. App., Mar. 1, 2018, No. B279364) 2018 WL 1127686, at *7 [nonpub. opn.].)

So a co-owner who argues today that partition should be denied because a sale would be unfair is raising an argument without merit. Courts do not reward stall tactics in partition cases: in Hummel v. First National Bank (1987) 191 Cal.App.3d 489, the Court of Appeal ordered a co-owner and his attorney to pay $50,000 for a frivolous appeal brought to delay a partition sale.

Fairness still matters in a partition, but in other places. Once the right to partition is established, the court weighs whether a sale or a physical division is more equitable under CCP 872.820’s rule on sale instead of division, and it adjusts each owner’s share for payments and use under CCP 872.140’s accounting rule. Fairness never decides whether a co-owner gets partition at all. As De Roulet v. Mitchel (1945) 70 Cal.App.2d 120, 124 put it, “in no event is a partition to be denied because it will result in financial loss to the cotenants.” (Quoted in AMI, at p. 1013.)

The Only Part of AMI Still Cited: Waiver by Agreement

The 1976 statute kept one defense, and AMI is still quoted for it. In LEG Investments v. Boxler (2010) 183 Cal.App.4th 484, 493, the Court of Appeal wrote that “A co-owner of property has an absolute right to partition unless barred by a valid waiver,” and quoted AMI for the point that “the right of partition may be waived by contract, either express or implied.” (AMI, at p. 1014.)

That is a narrow rule, and AMI is an unusual example of it: a state-approved investment plan, a written waiver in the permit application, and a 20-year hospital lease. Even there, partition was barred only until the lease ended in 1980. Courts look for an agreement that clearly rules partition out, as in Heber v. Yaeger, and in LEG Investments a right of first refusal only added a step before a partition sale. Our article on waiver of the right to partition explains what counts.

What AMI Means for California Co-Owners

  1. “A sale would be unfair to me” is not a defense. Under CCP 872.710(b), a co-owner has an absolute right to partition unless a valid waiver bars it.
  2. Check the date on any case your co-owner cites. AMI was decided under the statute the Legislature replaced in 1976, and so were Pine v. Tiedt and Penasquitos. Our article explaining why fairness is not a defense to partition covers the whole line of cases.
  3. Only a real agreement can stop a partition. Siblings who inherit a house, exes on title, and friends who bought together rarely have anything like the investor waiver in AMI.
  4. Fairness goes into the accounting, not the right. Payments, use of the property and similar claims are settled through offsets when the proceeds are divided.

Is Your Co-Owner Citing AMI? Enforce Your Right to Partition

If your co-owner says the court can stop a sale because it would be unfair, don’t let that argument slow you down. A partition action is how a California co-owner ends the co-ownership, and the right to file one does not depend on what your co-owner thinks is fair.

Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from proving your right to partition through the partition sale and the final distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online for a free 30-minute consultation.

Related partition content

Categories: Right to Partition, Defenses to Partition

Topics: , , ,

Statutes: , , ,

Cases: , , , , , , , , ,

Scott Talkov

About Scott Talkov

Scott Talkov founded Talkov Law, the first and largest law firm in the United States dedicated exclusively to partition actions. He oversees a team of 12 partition attorneys. He has handled more than 650 partition cases in 41 California counties, resolving over $400 million in co-owned real estate with zero partitions denied. He has been repeatedly selected to Super Lawyers, including the 2027 list.