Hummel v. First National Bank: $50,000 Sanctions for Appealing a Partition Sale to Delay

In Hummel v. First National Bank, a court upheld a partition sale without a minimum bid and imposed $50,000 in sanctions for an appeal brought to delay.

In Hummel v. First National Bank, the California Court of Appeal upheld a $12.35 million partition sale without a minimum bid and ordered a 1.5 percent owner and his attorney to pay $50,000 for an appeal brought only to delay.

A co-owner who appeals a partition sale just to buy time can end up paying for it. In Hummel v. First National Bank (1987) 191 Cal.App.3d 489, the Court of Appeal upheld a $12,350,000 partition sale of Beverly Hills land and ordered a 1.5 percent owner and his attorney to pay $50,000 in sanctions for a frivolous appeal. The court found the owner’s purpose was “purely dilatory.” (Hummel, at p. 495.)

The case also answers a question co-owners ask before a court-ordered sale: does the court have to set a minimum bid? The answer in Hummel was no, when the sale draws real competition and the price lands close to the appraised value.

Why Hummel v. First National Bank Matters

  1. No minimum bid was required. The trial court did not abuse its discretion by refusing to set a minimum bid before an auction that produced competitive bidding. (Hummel, at pp. 493–494.)
  2. A fair price is judged by the evidence. The sale price was within a fraction of a percent of the objecting owner’s own appraisal, so no harm resulted. (Hummel, at p. 494.)
  3. Delay has a price. The court ordered $25,000 paid by the owner and $25,000 paid by his attorney to the co-owner who bought the property. (Hummel, at p. 496.)

The Facts: Eleven Beverly Hills Lots and a 1.5 Percent Owner

The property was 11 lots in Beverly Hills, part of a 16-lot block bounded by Santa Monica Boulevard, Lasky Drive, Durant Drive, and Charleville Boulevard. Mont Pelerin Corporation owned 69 percent of the 11 lots and separately owned four of the other five lots on the block. Errett Allan Hummel held a 1.5 percent beneficial interest through a trust. (Hummel, at pp. 491–492.)

In 1982, the trial court entered an interlocutory judgment ordering the property sold. Hummel and other owners appealed and lost in 1984. Hummel then asked the court to order an appraisal and set a minimum bid as a term of the sale. He argued that the 11 lots were worth more to a buyer who also owned the neighboring four lots, so outside bidders would stay away and Mont Pelerin could buy cheaply. The court denied the request. (Hummel, at pp. 491–492.)

The partition referee advertised the sale in the Los Angeles Times, the Wall Street Journal, and several other papers. Bidders submitted sealed bids with a cashier’s check for 10 percent of the bid. The highest sealed bid was $8 million. At the live auction, the trustee of Hummel’s own trust bid $12,200,000. Mont Pelerin, bidding with a partner, won at $12,350,000. At the hearing to confirm the sale, the court invited overbids under Code of Civil Procedure section 873.740. No one made one, and the court confirmed the sale. (Hummel, at p. 492.)

Hummel then moved for reconsideration using an appraisal that valued the 11 lots at $12,400,000. The trial court denied the motion, and Hummel appealed. (Hummel, at pp. 492–493.)

How the Court of Appeal Decided the Case

The Sale Price Was Fair

The court framed the question narrowly:

“The only issue appropriately before us is whether the court’s failure to set a minimum bid caused the property to be sold at an unfair price. Appellant’s own evidence establishes that it did not.”

Hummel v. First National Bank (1987) 191 Cal.App.3d 489, 494

Hummel’s whole argument assumed nobody would compete with Mont Pelerin at the auction. “This assumption was not borne out.” (Hummel, at p. 494.) At least three bidders took part, including one with no connection to the lawsuit. The best minimum bid the court could have justified was Hummel’s own appraisal of $12,400,000, and the property sold for $12,350,000. The court called the difference de minimis, meaning too small to matter. (Hummel, at pp. 494–495.)

That result fits the partition statutes. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 873.730, which governs the confirmation hearing, the court can order a new sale if the price is disproportionate to the property’s value. The court’s power to refuse a bad price at confirmation is the safeguard, not a minimum bid set months before anyone has bid.

$50,000 in Sanctions for a Frivolous Appeal

Mont Pelerin asked for sanctions under Code of Civil Procedure section 907, which allows them for a frivolous appeal. The court found the appeal frivolous under both tests from the California Supreme Court: it was brought for an improper motive, and any reasonable attorney would agree it had no merit. (Hummel, at pp. 494–495.)

The court pointed to several problems. Hummel’s brief mostly reargued issues decided in the first appeal. It claimed Mont Pelerin made the only bid, which the record showed was false. It ignored the appraisal, the only valuation evidence in the record, because that appraisal supported the sale price. The court concluded that “appellant’s purpose, both in seeking reconsideration of the order confirming sale and in pursuing the matter on appeal, was purely dilatory.” (Hummel, at p. 495.)

The size of Hummel’s stake mattered too. “Appellant’s own de minimus interest in the property provides additional confirmation that this appeal could not have been undertaken for a proper purpose,” especially when owners with much larger shares did not appeal. (Hummel, at p. 495.) The court affirmed the judgment and ordered Hummel and his attorney to pay $25,000 each to Mont Pelerin. (Hummel, at p. 496.)

What Hummel Means for California Co-Owners

  1. A well-run sale is hard to overturn. Wide advertising, sealed bids, a live auction, and an open call for overbids at confirmation produced a price the courts would not disturb. Our guide to whether a partition sale yields fair market value explains why these sales usually reach market price.
  2. Price fights belong at the confirmation hearing. The court reviews the price under CCP 873.730 and can accept a higher bid under CCP 873.740’s overbid rule. Evidence held back until later carries little weight.
  3. Owning a neighboring parcel is not unfair. A co-owner who owns adjoining land may value the property more and may bid on it. That alone did not make the sale unfair in Hummel.
  4. Appeals filed only to delay can cost real money. Courts can sanction both the co-owner and the attorney, and the money goes to the co-owner who had to respond.

For more on the sale process, see our guides to partition procedure and whether a partition referee is necessary, and our page on CCP 873.750’s rules for completing a confirmed sale. Related cases include De Uprey v. De Uprey, where delay tactics could not stop a partition, De Roulet v. Mitchel, where a co-owner could not delay a sale to wait for a better market, and Sullivan v. Dorsa, where owners could not veto a sale already reported to the court.

Ready to Move a Partition Sale Forward?

A partition action moves from the complaint to an interlocutory judgment and a court-supervised sale. Hummel shows that courts protect a fair sale from late challenges meant only to delay it.

Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from the complaint through the partition sale and the final distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.

Related partition content

Categories: Partition by Sale, Judgments & Appeals

Topics: , , ,

Statutes: , ,

Cases:

Scott Talkov

About Scott Talkov

Scott Talkov founded Talkov Law, the first and largest law firm in the United States dedicated exclusively to partition actions. He oversees a team of 12 partition attorneys. He has handled more than 650 partition cases in 41 California counties, resolving over $400 million in co-owned real estate with zero partitions denied. He has been repeatedly selected to Super Lawyers, including the 2027 list.