Pine v. Tiedt

Fairness defense to partition, absolute right to partition, court-ordered sale, California: judge points to a sale order despite a co-owner's fairness objection

“Fairness” is Not a Defense to Partition

A 1976 case suggested fairness could limit partition, but the Legislature that same year made partition a matter of right unless validly waived. California courts have since rejected the fairness defense.

How to win a partition action, California partition strategy, force the sale: smiling couple holds sale documents beside a sold sign

How to Win a Partition Action

How a co-owner who wants out wins a partition action in California: force the sale or a buyout, answer the defenses your co-owner will raise, maximize your offsets, and build your record from day one.