“Fairness” is Not a Defense to Partition

Fairness is not a defense to partition. AMI v. Feller and Pine v. Tiedt predate California’s 1976 statute making clear that the right to partition is absolute.

Fairness defense to partition, absolute right to partition, court-ordered sale, California: judge points to a sale order despite a co-owner's fairness objection

“Fairness” is not a defense to partition in California. Arguing that a court should deny partition because a sale would be unfair is without merit, because the Legislature rewrote the partition statutes in 1976. The argument comes from American Medical International, Inc. v. Feller (1976) 59 Cal.App.3d 1008 (“AMI”), a case decided under the former partition statute. That same year, the Legislature enacted Code of Civil Procedure section 872.710, which provides that partition “shall be as of right unless barred by a valid waiver.” The statute has no fairness exception. AMI and the older cases behind it have been superseded by statute. They do not represent the current state of the law, which is that California co-owners have an absolute right to partition. Courts called the right absolute long before the statute did. Priddel v. Shankie (1945) 69 Cal.App.2d 319, 325.

Is your co-owner calling a sale unfair? That argument doesn’t stop a partition. Get a free 30-minute consultation or call (877) PARTITION (727-8484). No fees until you win.

The Supposed “Fairness” Defense to Partition

Defendants in partition actions sometimes try to delay the case by arguing that a general “requirement of fairness” lets a court refuse partition. The argument is without merit. It rests on cases decided before the Legislature wrote the right to partition into the statute in 1976, and it is not the current law.

This argument is usually based on language from American Medical International, Inc. v. Feller (1976) 59 Cal.App.3d 1008, 1015–1016 (“AMI”), which in turn cites Penasquitos, Inc. v. Holladay (1972) 27 Cal.App.3d 356. Both cases were decided under the former partition statute, so neither one establishes a fairness-based defense to partition under today’s law.

In AMI, the court did describe a “requirement of fairness” as “an even wider and more general limitation” on partition than a waiver. (AMI, 59 Cal.App.3d at p. 1015.) Penasquitos is the case AMI took that phrase from. Defendants may also cite Pine v. Tiedt (1965) 232 Cal.App.2d 733, 738, which said the right to partition is subject to waiver by an implied agreement “when an inequity would result.” All three cases were decided before the Legislature enacted CCP 872.710(b)’s right to partition in 1976, and none of them represents the current state of the law.

Under today’s statute, there is no fairness exception to apply. Co-owners have an absolute right to partition unless a valid waiver bars it, and a co-owner who argues that a sale should be stopped because it would be unfair is raising an argument without merit.

Fairness still has a place in a partition, but only after the right to partition is decided. The court weighs what is more equitable in choosing between a sale and a physical division under CCP 872.820’s rule on sale instead of division, and it adjusts each owner’s share for payments and use under CCP 872.140’s accounting rule. Fairness never decides whether a co-owner gets partition at all, and hardship to the co-owner who wants to keep the property is not a defense. As De Roulet v. Mitchel (1945) 70 Cal.App.2d 120, 124 put it, “in no event is a partition to be denied because it will result in financial loss to the cotenants.”

Courts turned away the same argument in other forms long before 1976. In De Roulet v. Mitchel, a co-owner could not hold up a sale because the building had a good lease and might rise in value. In Priddel v. Shankie, a homestead that a co-owner recorded on his half did not stop the court-ordered sale of a Los Angeles lot. In Lazzarevich v. Lazzarevich (1952) 39 Cal.2d 48, 50–51, an unpaid judgment owed to the other co-owner could not defeat the right to partition. AMI’s “requirement of fairness” was out of step with these cases the day it was written, and the Legislature ended the debate that same year. Our guide to the absolute right to partition lists the other arguments that do not stop a partition.

Court of Appeal Has Twice Rejected that “Fairness” is a Defense to Partition

Twice in the last few years, the Court of Appeal has informed litigants that the fairness defense cases interpreted the partition statutes in effect before 1976, not the statute that now makes partition a matter of right.

In 2023, the Court of Appeal, Second District covering Los Angeles and the Central Coast found that: “The AMI decision, however, does not address section 872.710, which was enacted the same year AMI was decided. Rather, AMI was decided under the former statute, section 752, which did not provide for an absolute right of partition. (See AMI, supra, 59 Cal.App.3d at p. 1013 [quoting former section 752, which provided that ‘[when] several cotenants own real property … an action may be brought by one or more of such persons, … for a partition thereof according to the respective rights of the persons interested therein’].) Because AMI does not address section 872.710, it does not guide our analysis.” (Caiozzo v. 2672 to 2674 North Beachwood Drive, LLC (Nov. 13, 2023, B322219) 2023 WL 7485496, at p. *6 [nonpub. opn.].)

This is the second time that the Court of Appeal has been called upon to inform defendants of the bogus nature of this claim, telling the now disgraced and disbarred Tom Girardi as Appellant/Defendant that the AMI case “does not address Code of Civil Procedure section 872.710, which was enacted the same year that AMI was decided. Therefore, AMI does not guide our analysis on this point.” (Lipscomb v. Girardi (Mar. 1, 2018, B279364) 2018 WL 1127686, at p. *7 [nonpub. opn.].)

The message is plain: the fairness argument has been superseded by statute. It does not represent the current state of California law, and a co-owner who raises it today is raising an argument without merit. Courts have little patience for arguments brought to stall a partition. In Hummel v. First National Bank (1987) 191 Cal.App.3d 489, the Court of Appeal ordered a co-owner and his attorney to pay $50,000 for a frivolous appeal brought to delay a partition sale.

Both cases grew out of unusual investor deals, not ordinary co-ownership: fractions of a Los Angeles hospital sold to investors in AMI, and a sanitarium built by an investor group in Pine. Penasquitos was similar: a 99-year lease and purchase option on San Diego land. Our case summaries of American Medical International v. Feller, Pine v. Tiedt and Penasquitos v. Holladay explain what each court decided and why neither one is a fairness defense today.

Absolute Right to Partition is Still the Law in California

Since the Legislature enacted the current partition statutes in 1976, the law has been that “partition as to concurrent interests in the property shall be as of right unless barred by a valid waiver.” CCP 872.710(b). As such: “A co-owner of property has an absolute right to partition unless barred by a valid waiver.” LEG Investments v. Boxler (2010) 183 Cal.App.4th 484, 493; see Priddel v. Shankie (1945) 69 Cal.App.2d 319, 325 (“Ordinarily, if the party seeking partition is shown to be a tenant in common, and as such entitled to the possession of the land sought to be partitioned, the right to partition is absolute, and cannot be denied, ‘either because of any supposed difficulty, nor on the suggestion that the interest of the cotenants will be promoted by refusing the application or temporarily postponing action….”).

Courts said the same thing before 1976 and have kept saying it since. Heber v. Yaeger (1967) 251 Cal.App.2d 258, 262 held that “the right of a cotenant to partition is absolute except where denied or limited by agreement expressed or implied.” Fifty years later, Orien v. Lutz (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 957, 962 repeated that “A co-owner of property has an absolute right to partition unless barred by a valid waiver.” From 1945 to today, the only thing that has limited the right is an agreement between the co-owners, never a judge’s sense of what is fair.

Co-Owner Arguing “Fairness”? Enforce Your Absolute Right to Partition

Plaintiffs in partition actions need a partition attorney who can overcome stall tactics like the fairness argument. Defendants should know which theories are real defenses to a partition action and which are misreadings of the law. Fairness is a misreading, and the absolute right to partition lets a co-owner end the co-ownership through a partition action.

Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from proving your right to partition through the partition sale and the final distribution of proceeds. No fees until you win. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) or contact us online for a free 30-minute consultation.

Related partition content

Categories: Right to Partition, Defenses to Partition

Topics: , ,

Statutes: , ,

Cases: , , , , , , , , , , ,

Scott Talkov

About Scott Talkov

Scott Talkov founded Talkov Law, the first and largest law firm in the United States dedicated exclusively to partition actions. He oversees a team of 12 partition attorneys. He has handled more than 650 partition cases in 41 California counties, resolving over $400 million in co-owned real estate with zero partitions denied. He has been repeatedly selected to Super Lawyers, including the 2027 list.