A mortgage on the property does not stop a partition, and neither does a co-owner who refuses to sell until the market improves. In Rich v. Smith (1915) 26 Cal.App. 775, the California Court of Appeal affirmed the partition of land that carried mortgages and unfinished sale contracts. It called the request to hold off until prices improved “utterly untenable.” (Rich, at p. 783.)
The court also upheld a lien on the other co-owner’s share for money the plaintiff had advanced for the property. This post covers what the court decided and the statutes that apply today.
Why Rich v. Smith Matters
- A mortgage or an unfinished sale contract does not block partition. Lenders and buyers keep their rights in the parcels they hold, and the co-owners still get their partition. (Rich, at pp. 780–782.)
- A co-owner cannot wait out the market. Partition cannot be denied or postponed so that the owners can capture a rise in values. (Rich, at p. 783.)
- Advances can be secured by a lien. Money one co-owner put in for the common benefit can be charged against the other co-owner’s share. (Rich, at pp. 784–785.)
- A deed that states no shares means equal shares. Two people named on a deed are presumed to own half each unless something shows otherwise. (Rich, at p. 784.)
The Facts: Mortgaged Land in San Mateo County
George O. Rich and C. B. Smith owned several tracts of land in San Mateo County. They had sold some parcels, signed contracts to sell others that had not yet closed, and mortgaged separate parcels. The mortgages still carried $38,879.82 in unpaid principal. (Rich, at pp. 777–778.)
Rich sued for partition. He named the lenders and the contract buyers as defendants, and he alleged that he had advanced more than Smith to improve the property and pay off liens. Smith denied that the two were co-owners at all. He claimed the land was held for a partnership, and he filed a cross-complaint to quiet title and for damages. (Rich, at pp. 777–778.)
The trial court found that Rich and Smith were tenants in common, each with an undivided one-half interest, and that there was no partnership. It ordered the land physically divided between them, with the mortgages and sale contracts left in place on the parcels they covered. It also gave Rich a lien on Smith’s share for half of the $21,485.83 Rich had advanced. (Rich, at pp. 778–780.) Smith appealed.
How the Court of Appeal Decided the Case
Mortgages and Sale Contracts Do Not Prevent Partition
Smith argued that the mortgages and the unfinished sale contracts ruled out any partition. (Rich, at p. 780.) The court disagreed. The lenders and buyers kept their rights in the particular parcels, and the referees dividing the land could treat those parcels “as so many distinct estates, and separately partition them as such,” allotting each one to Rich or Smith subject to its mortgage or contract. (Rich, at pp. 780–782.)
Smith worried that one of them might end up paying a whole mortgage debt. The court answered that a co-owner who pays more than his share “will be rightfully and readily subrogated, to the extent of the excess payment, to the interests of the mortgagee.” (Rich, at p. 782.) In plain terms, the co-owner who overpays steps into the lender’s shoes for the extra amount. For how mortgage payments are credited between co-owners today, see I paid the mortgage. Can I get it back in a partition?
No Waiting for a Better Market
Both sides agreed that selling the land at that time would have been a financial disaster, and the Court of Appeal assumed that was why the trial court ordered it physically divided instead. Smith objected to that too. The court saw that his real position was that “partition of any kind should be denied until such time as partition would result in the fullest profit to both parties.” (Rich, at p. 783.) It rejected that position outright:
“This position is utterly untenable. Ordinarily, if the party seeking partition is shown to be a tenant in common, and as such entitled to the possession of the land sought to be partitioned, the right to partition is absolute, and cannot be denied, ‘either because of any supposed difficulty, nor on the suggestion that the interest of the cotenants will be promoted by refusing the application or temporarily postponing action, to secure the advantages to result from a rise in market values.'”
Rich v. Smith (1915) 26 Cal.App. 775, 783
Courts have applied that rule in bad markets ever since. In Harper v. Superior Court (1934) 140 Cal.App. 5, 6, decided during the Great Depression, the co-owners resisting the partition of a house argued that a sale would be unwise “because of the present depressed condition of real property values.” The Court of Appeal said that Rich v. Smith “states the accepted rule.” In Cohen v. Karubian (1969) 276 Cal.App.2d 44, 48–49, a co-owner complained that a sale would force buyers to refinance “in a tight money market.” The court answered by quoting the passage above.
Priddel v. Shankie (1945) 69 Cal.App.2d 319, 325 quoted the same rule. De Roulet v. Mitchel (1945) 70 Cal.App.2d 120, 124 cited Rich v. Smith alongside De Uprey v. De Uprey (1865) 27 Cal. 329 for the rule that “in no event is a partition to be denied because it will result in financial loss to the cotenants.” A co-owner worried about price has a better answer than delay: the sale process is built to reach fair market value in a partition sale. And once the property sells, Dunn v. Dunn (1902) 137 Cal. 51 holds that a vague claim the price was too low will not undo a fair sale.
One tract had been deeded to Rich and Smith together without stating their shares. An earlier contract between them split the profits from that tract one-third to Rich and two-thirds to Smith, but the court held that the contract “was not conclusive evidence of the interest actually owned by each cotenant.” A deed to two people that names no shares is presumed to give each an undivided half, and other evidence supported that reading. (Rich, at p. 784.)
The court also upheld the lien on Smith’s share for the money Rich had advanced for their common benefit. It relied on Ventre v. Tiscornia (1913) 23 Cal.App. 598 and on Willmon v. Koyer (1914) 168 Cal. 369, where the California Supreme Court said of such a lien that “it is always appropriate to do so in partition as the only effectual way to secure a cotenant making advances and obtaining judgment therefor.” (Rich, at p. 785, quoting Willmon.) Southern Adjustment Bureau, Inc. v. Nelson (1964) 230 Cal.App.2d 539, 541 later cited Rich v. Smith for a co-owner’s right to be repaid those advances.
The Result
The Court of Appeal affirmed the judgment ordering partition. (Rich, at p. 786.) The California Supreme Court declined to hear the case on May 13, 1915.
The Statutes on Mortgages and Liens in a Partition Today
Rich v. Smith was decided under the former partition law. The current California partition statutes, enacted in 1976, keep its rules:
- The court sorts out the liens. CCP 872.630 on the status and priority of liens directs the court to “determine the status and priority of all liens upon the property.”
- In a sale, the mortgage is paid from the proceeds. Under CCP 873.820 on the application of sale proceeds, the money from the sale pays the expenses of sale and the costs of partition first, then “any liens on the property in their order of priority,” other than a lien the sale leaves in place. The rest goes to the co-owners according to their shares.
- The market is not a defense. Under CCP 872.710 on the right to partition, partition between co-owners “shall be as of right unless barred by a valid waiver.”
- Advances are repaid. CCP 872.140 on compensatory adjustment lets the court order “allowance, accounting, contribution, or other compensatory adjustment among the parties according to the principles of equity.”
One thing has changed in favor of the co-owner who wants out. The land in Rich v. Smith was physically divided, under a former law that allowed a sale only on a showing of great prejudice. Today, CCP 872.820 on partition by sale calls for a sale when the co-owners agree to one or when a sale “would be more equitable than division of the property.” That is why co-owned houses are routinely sold in a partition by sale instead of being split.
What Rich v. Smith Means for California Co-Owners
- A mortgage is not a reason to stay stuck. If you are dealing with a co-owner not paying the mortgage, the loan does not stop you from filing. The lender is named in the case, and in a sale its loan is paid from the proceeds before the co-owners are paid.
- “Wait until the market comes back” is not a defense. A co-owner’s wish for a better price later does not postpone your right to partition now.
- Keep records of what you paid. Mortgage payments, lien payoffs, and repairs and improvements you covered can be claimed as offsets and charged against the other owner’s share.
- Read the deed. If it states no shares, the court starts from equal ownership. A co-owner who claims a larger share has to prove it, as our article on unequal down payments explains.
Co-Owner Says Now Is Not the Time? The Law Says Otherwise
Rich v. Smith is more than a century old, and its point has not changed: a co-owner does not have to wait for the other owner’s preferred moment. If your co-owner is pointing to the mortgage, a pending deal, or the market as a reason to hold off, talk to a partition attorney about filing a partition action.
Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from the complaint through the referee’s sale and the final distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.







