Dunn v. Dunn: A Partition Sale Can’t Be Thrown Out on Vague Claims the Price Was Too Low

In Dunn v. Dunn, vague claims that the price was too low could not undo a fair partition sale. Value is measured on the date of the sale.

In Dunn v. Dunn, the California Supreme Court held that a court may not refuse to confirm a fairly conducted partition sale based on vague testimony that the property was worth more, and that value is measured as of the date of the sale, not the later confirmation hearing.

After a partition referee sells the property, the sale goes back to the court to be confirmed on a motion under Code of Civil Procedure section 873.720 (CCP 873.720, the motion to confirm or set aside a sale). That hearing is where an unhappy co-owner may try to undo the sale by saying the price was too low. In Dunn v. Dunn (1902) 137 Cal. 51, the California Supreme Court held that a court’s power to refuse confirmation is “a sound judicial discretion,” not an arbitrary one, and that general testimony that the property was worth “more” is not enough to throw out a fair sale. Value is measured on the day of the sale, not months later after the market has moved.

Why Dunn v. Dunn Matters

  1. The buyer has rights. The winning bidder becomes a party to the case, is entitled to confirmation unless the law gives a reason to refuse it, and can appeal if confirmation is denied.
  2. Objections need real numbers. A court needs tangible evidence of what the property was worth, not an opinion that it should have brought more.
  3. Value is fixed on the sale date. A rise in prices after the sale belongs to the buyer.
  4. A slow market is not enough by itself. “It was a bad time to sell” does not undo a sale the co-owners asked the court to order.

The Facts: Four San Francisco Parcels Sold at Auction

Thomas F. Dunn filed a partition action in 1897 over real property in San Francisco. In March 1898, the court entered an interlocutory judgment finding that the property could not be divided without great prejudice to the owners, ordering a sale, and appointing a single referee, G. H. Umbsen, with the agreement of all parties.

The referee advertised the sale widely. (Today, notice of a partition sale is governed by CCP 873.640’s notice of sale rules.) No bids came in on the first auction date in May 1898. At a second auction on September 12, 1898, the four parcels sold for $3,400, $6,600, $15,500, and $1,300. H. E. Bothin bought the third parcel for $15,500 and paid a 10 percent deposit.

Six months later, at the confirmation hearing in March 1899, several co-owners objected that every price was inadequate, the kind of last-minute resistance a co-owner who refuses to sell often tries. That was their only objection. The referee testified that $15,500 was the best price he could get, although it was a hard time to sell because of “the war excitement.” Two real estate agents testified that the Bothin parcel had been worth more than $15,500 at the time of the sale but would not say how much more. One added that values had risen since and that the parcel was now worth $22,500. The trial court confirmed two of the sales but refused to confirm the sale to Bothin and ordered a resale. Bothin appealed.

How the Supreme Court Decided the Case

The Buyer Could Appeal

The co-owners argued that Bothin had no right to appeal. The court disagreed, relying on Hammond v. Cailleaud (1896) 111 Cal. 206. By buying at the sale, Bothin became a party to the action and submitted to the court’s authority over the sale. When confirmation was refused, he was a party aggrieved by the order and could appeal it. For what an appeal does to a partition sale today, see Does Appealing a Partition Judgment Stop the Sale in California?

Confirmation Is a Judicial Decision, Not an Arbitrary One

The co-owners relied on old English practice, under which any offer to raise the bid was enough to reopen a court sale. The Supreme Court said California does not follow that rule. A bidder takes on obligations by bidding and gains rights in return:

“The court doubtless has the power to confirm or refuse to confirm, but we do not think that this is an arbitrary power; it is neither more nor less than a sound judicial discretion, and must be exercised with a just regard to the rights of all concerned.”

Dunn v. Dunn (1902) 137 Cal. 51, 59

Value Is Measured at the Time of the Sale

The court held that it “must look to the value of the property at the time of the sale, and not to the time when the question of confirmation is before the court.” The evidence showed only that values had gone up after the sale and that the parcel had been worth some unstated amount “more” when it sold. That testimony would be satisfied by a slight difference, and a slight difference does not justify a resale. In the cases where a low price had been enough, the gap between the price and the market value was a considerable sum, and the court had been told what it was.

The court gave little weight to the slow market. Those conditions existed when the parties asked for the sale and agreed on the referee, and two of the parcels had sold at prices the trial court accepted. In the court’s words, “[t]he mere statement that it was a bad time to sell, or that there was not much demand for real property at the time, is too vague and uncertain” to guide a court. The court did not decide whether a low price alone can ever justify refusing confirmation.

The Law Today: Price Objections Under the 1976 Partition Law

California rewrote its partition statutes in 1976, and they now spell out when a court may refuse to confirm a sale. The buyer, the referee, or any party may ask the court to confirm or set aside the sale on at least 10 days’ notice under CCP 873.720. At the hearing, CCP 873.730’s grounds for vacating a partition sale allow the court to order a new sale only if it finds one of three things:

  • Unfairness or bad notice. The proceedings were unfair or notice of sale was not properly given. If the court makes no such finding at the hearing, the sale cannot be attacked on those grounds later.
  • A disproportionate price. The court finds that “the sale price is disproportionate to the value of the property.”
  • A clearly better resale. A new sale will bring at least 10 percent more on the first $10,000 and 5 percent more on the rest, after a reasonable allowance for the expenses of a new sale.

Under CCP 873.740’s increased-offer rule, a responsible bidder can also make a written offer at the hearing that beats the sale price by the same 10 percent and 5 percent margins. The court may then order a new sale, or accept the higher offer and confirm the sale to that bidder. Either way, a claim that the price was too low needs proof of value or a real buyer with a higher written offer, which is the lesson of Dunn. Once the sale is confirmed, the referee completes it under CCP 873.750’s rules for closing a confirmed sale.

Price Under the Partition of Real Property Act

For partition actions filed on or after January 1, 2023, over property held as tenants in common with no written agreement governing partition, the Partition of Real Property Act applies under CCP 874.311, and it controls over any conflicting partition statute under CCP 874.313. The Act moves the question of price to the front of the case:

  • Value is set before the sale. Under CCP 874.316’s fair market value rule, the court usually orders an appraisal by a disinterested licensed appraiser, unless the co-owners agree on the value or the court finds an appraisal is not worth its cost. A party may object within 30 days after notice of the appraisal, and the court then holds a hearing, where it may consider other evidence of value, and fixes the fair market value before it decides the partition itself.
  • The broker cannot sell below that value. Under CCP 874.320’s open-market sale rule, the sale is usually a listing by a court-appointed licensed broker, who must offer the property “at a price no lower than the determination of value.” The broker reports a qualifying offer to the court under CCP 874.321’s broker’s report rule.
  • If no buyer pays that price. After a hearing, the court may approve the highest outstanding offer, redetermine the value and keep the property on the market, or order a sale by sealed bids or at auction. An auction follows the 1976 sale procedures that begin at CCP 873.510.

Under the Act, the main fight over price happens at the valuation hearing, before the property is ever listed. A buyer who pays at least the court’s value has paid the price the court itself set.

The Result

The Supreme Court reversed and directed the trial court to confirm the sale to Bothin at $15,500.

What Dunn v. Dunn Means for California Co-Owners

  1. A fair sale is hard to undo. If the referee marketed the property properly, a co-owner’s belief that it should have sold for more will not stop confirmation. That is good news for the co-owner who wants the partition by sale finished.
  2. Bring an appraisal or a better offer. A co-owner who thinks the price is short of fair market value in a partition sale needs a figure tied to the sale date or a qualifying overbid.
  3. Later appreciation belongs to the buyer. Six months passed between the sale and the hearing in Dunn, and the rise in value during that time could not be used against the buyer.
  4. Market timing does not reopen a sale. Courts have little patience for efforts to stall a sale that has been ordered, as Hummel v. First National Bank also shows, and Rich v. Smith holds that a co-owner cannot delay partition to wait for a rise in market values.

Ready to Get Your Co-Owned Property Sold?

Dunn v. Dunn protects the finality of a partition sale that was run fairly. If you want to force the sale of a house you co-own and have the proceeds divided, a partition attorney can guide the case through the sale, the confirmation hearing, and closing.

Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from the complaint through the referee’s sale and the final distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.

Related partition content

Categories: Partition by Sale, Judgments & Appeals

Topics: , , ,

Statutes: , , , , , , , , ,

Cases: , ,

Scott Talkov

About Scott Talkov

Scott Talkov founded Talkov Law, the first and largest law firm in the United States dedicated exclusively to partition actions. He oversees a team of 12 partition attorneys. He has handled more than 650 partition cases in 41 California counties, resolving over $400 million in co-owned real estate with zero partitions denied. He has been repeatedly selected to Super Lawyers, including the 2027 list.