A co-owner who rents out the property and keeps the money has to share it. In Goodenow v. Ewer (1860) 16 Cal. 461, 471–472, the California Supreme Court held that in a partition action, a co-owner who collected rent from tenants must account to the other owners for their share. He could subtract the property taxes he paid and the cost of necessary repairs, but he could not charge the other owners for his own time managing the building. If this is happening to you now, our guide on what to do when your co-owner is collecting the rent and not paying you half walks through the steps.
Why Goodenow Matters
- Rent from tenants belongs to all the owners. The co-owner who collects it must account for the others’ shares. (Goodenow, at p. 472.)
- Taxes and necessary repairs come off the top. The collecting owner is credited for what he paid to keep the building up. (Goodenow, at p. 472.)
- No management fee. A co-owner cannot bill the others for his time renting the property and collecting the rent. (Goodenow, at p. 472.)
- The accounting is part of the partition. The court that orders the sale also settles who owes whom. (Goodenow, at p. 472.)
- Each owner is paid for the share it really owns. Sale money is divided by actual ownership, minus each owner’s share of the costs. (Goodenow, at p. 471.)
The Facts: The Metropolitan Theater in Oroville
Downer and Morris each owned an undivided half of a lot in Oroville, in Butte County, with a building known as the Metropolitan Theater. In May 1857, Downer mortgaged only his own share, his half, to the Goodenows to secure a $2,000 note. The next month, Downer and Morris sold an undivided one-third of the whole property to Ewer, so Downer, Morris and Ewer each owned a third as tenants in common. (Goodenow, at pp. 464–466.)
When Downer didn’t pay, the Goodenows foreclosed. They named only Downer in the lawsuit, not Ewer. At the sheriff’s sale in June 1858, they bought for the full amount of the judgment, and they received a sheriff’s deed in January 1859. Meanwhile, Ewer bought out the rest of Downer’s and Morris’s interests, took possession, and rented the theater rooms to theatrical companies, which one co-owner can do without the others’ consent. (Goodenow, at pp. 464–466, 472.)
The Goodenows sued for a partition sale, because the property could not be divided without harming the owners, and for an accounting of the rent Ewer collected. The trial court found the Goodenows owned one-third and ordered the property sold. But it gave them a share of the rent for only the six months between the sheriff’s sale and the sheriff’s deed, and nothing after. The Goodenows appealed. (Goodenow, at pp. 464–465, 471.)
How the Supreme Court Decided the Case
The Goodenows argued they had bought Downer’s original half. But Ewer was never named in their foreclosure, so it reached only the third Downer still owned. The court held their share of the sale money was one-third, minus their share of the costs of the case, the same way partition fees are still shared by ownership today. (Goodenow, at pp. 469, 471.)
The Co-Owner Collecting the Rent Must Account for It
The trial court was wrong to cut off the rent after the sheriff’s deed; the Goodenows had a clear right to their share of it. (Goodenow, at p. 471.) The court explained that this case was about rent Ewer received from tenants, not profits he made by his own work while living on the property himself. For rent received from tenants, the answer was clear:
“Of rents thus received, the jurisdiction of equity to direct an account, as an incident to a partition, is unquestionable.”
Goodenow v. Ewer (1860) 16 Cal. 461, 472
What Comes Off the Top, and What Doesn’t
The court then set the rules for the accounting:
“From these rents the defendant is entitled to deduct the amount of the taxes paid, and of the expenses incurred in making necessary and proper repairs and additions, for the preservation and security of the buildings, during the period for which the rents were collected.”
Goodenow v. Ewer (1860) 16 Cal. 461, 472
In today’s terms, these are the property taxes credited in Southern Adjustment Bureau v. Nelson and the necessary improvements credited in Ventre v. Tiscornia. Ewer could also take a reasonable allowance for his own carpets, lamps and scenery, because the theater could not have been rented without them. But he was not entitled to anything for his own property that wasn’t needed to rent the building, “nor to any allowances for his personal services in taking charge of the building, renting the same, and collecting the rents.” (Goodenow, at p. 472.)
The Result
The Supreme Court affirmed the ownership shares, the order of sale and the confirmation of the referee’s sale, the same step later cases like Dunn v. Dunn and Parker v. Owen address. It sent the case back for a new accounting that included the rent Ewer collected after the sheriff’s deed, with the deductions the court allowed. (Goodenow, at pp. 472–473.)
Is Goodenow Still the Law?
Yes, on rent. In Heber v. Yaeger (1967) 251 Cal.App.2d 258, 264–265, the Court of Appeal cited Goodenow for a co-owner’s right to an accounting from the co-owner managing the property. In Combs v. Ritter (1950) 100 Cal.App.2d 315, the court relied on Goodenow to deny a co-owner pay for managing an apartment building when there was no agreement to pay her, while allowing a reasonable charge for her own furniture that was needed to rent the apartments furnished. By contrast, in Randell v. Randell (1935) 4 Cal.2d 575, a co-owner whose co-owners had agreed to pay him for managing the family orange ranch was paid, though only at the reasonable value of the work. And in Rutledge v. Rutledge, the Court of Appeal again required a co-owner who collected rent from tenants to account for it.
Today, Code of Civil Procedure section 872.140 (CCP 872.140) puts this power in the partition statutes: “The court may, in all cases, order allowance, accounting, contribution, or other compensatory adjustment among the parties according to the principles of equity.” CCP 872.140’s rule on accounting and compensatory adjustment is how rent, taxes and repairs are settled in a modern partition.
What Goodenow Means for California Co-Owners
- Rent collected is rent shared. Whether the property is a duplex, an apartment building or a home rented by the night, your share of the net rent is yours, one of the basic rights of every co-owner. The same goes for a co-owner who short-term rents the property without permission.
- Expect fair credits, and only fair credits. Taxes and necessary repairs are deducted, and a co-owner who paid the mortgage or paid for them can be credited for repairs and improvements. These all go into the partition accounting.
- “I did all the work” does not earn a fee. Without an agreement to pay for management, the managing co-owner’s time is not charged to the others.
- Living there is different from renting it out. Goodenow is about rent received from tenants. A co-owner who lives in the property is treated differently: usually there is no charge for living there unless there has been an ouster, as in Carpentier v. Webster. See when a co-owner owes rental value.
Co-Owner Keeping the Rent? End It With a Partition
If a co-owner is collecting rent on a property you own together and not paying you your share, a partition action ends the co-ownership and settles what you are owed. Your co-owner cannot stop it, because the right to partition is absolute unless it was waived.
Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from proving your right to partition through the partition sale and the final division of proceeds. No fees until you win. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online for a free consultation.








