A co-owner cannot pick out a piece of the property, call it “my share,” and keep the other owners out of it. In Carpentier v. Webster (1865) 27 Cal. 524, the California Supreme Court held that a co-owner who enclosed 60 acres of a shared rancho and refused to let another owner in had committed an ouster, even though the 60 acres was less than the land his share would have given him. Until the property is partitioned, every co-owner may use every part of it. If this is happening to you, our guide to a co-owner occupying part of the property explains what to do about it.
Why Carpentier Matters
- Every co-owner may use every part of the property. A co-owner’s share is a percentage of the whole, not a particular section of it. (Carpentier, at pp. 545–546.)
- “I only took my share” is not a defense. Occupying less than your percentage does not give you the right to keep another owner out of that part. (Carpentier, at p. 546.)
- Refusing to let a co-owner in is the ouster. Living on part of the land is allowed. Refusing to share it after a demand is not. (Carpentier, at p. 546.)
- Only a partition gives an owner land of their own. Before partition, no owner can point to a piece and call it theirs alone. (Carpentier, at p. 546.)
The Facts: Sixty Fenced Acres on the Rancho San Ramon
The Rancho San Ramon in Contra Costa County came from a Mexican land grant. By the 1860s it was owned by many people as tenants in common, meaning co-owners who each hold an undivided share, and it had never been surveyed or partitioned. Horace Carpentier owned at least an undivided half. Greene Webster owned an undivided one-eightieth, which by his own count would come to about 110 acres. (Carpentier, at pp. 541–542.)
Webster had enclosed about 60 acres near the middle of the rancho, where he lived, farmed, and put up buildings. In December 1862, Carpentier went to the property and demanded, in writing and in person, to be let into possession of that land along with Webster. Webster refused. He said he owned an interest in the rancho, “was in possession of no more than he was entitled to,” and would not let Carpentier in unless a lawsuit forced him to. (Carpentier, at pp. 542–543.)
Carpentier sued to be let into possession and for the value of the use of the land. The trial judge told the jury there was no evidence of an ouster, and the jury found for Webster. Carpentier appealed. (Carpentier, at pp. 541–544.)
How the Supreme Court Decided the Case
Webster’s main argument was that he had a right to hold the 60 acres alone because it was less than his share. The court rejected it. Co-owners share one thing above all, the right to possess the property together, and under that rule “each and every of them has the right to enter upon and occupy the whole of the common lands and every part thereof.” (Carpentier, at p. 545.)
The court explained why no owner can choose a section for himself: “Before partition, a tenant in common has no share, except one which is undivided.” (Carpentier, at p. 546.) Our article on what an undivided interest means covers this idea in plain terms, and our guide to the rights of a 50% owner lists what each co-owner can and cannot do.
Living There Is Fine. Keeping a Co-Owner Out Is an Ouster.
The court drew a careful line. Webster did nothing wrong by living on and farming the 60 acres. The wrong was refusing to let Carpentier use that land with him:
“It is true that the bare occupation of the sixty acres by the defendant is not inconsistent with the common title; but couple with that occupation a refusal on his part to allow the plaintiff to enter upon and occupy the sixty acres with him, and we have then a possession in him that is not consistent with the common title, and which, therefore, does amount to an ouster.”
Carpentier v. Webster (1865) 27 Cal. 524, 546
Later cases found an ouster in other ways of keeping a co-owner out. In De Harlan v. Harlan, a co-owner locked the other owner out of the home. In Estate of Hughes, a co-owner claimed in court that he owned 100 percent of the house.
The Result
The Supreme Court reversed the judgment for Webster and ordered a new trial. Carpentier’s demand and Webster’s refusal were evidence of an ouster that the jury should have been allowed to consider.
Is Carpentier Still the Law?
Yes. In Zaslow v. Kroenert (1946) 29 Cal.2d 541, 548, the California Supreme Court cited Carpentier and restated the rule: “Each tenant in common equally is entitled to share in the possession of the entire property and neither may exclude the other from any part of it.” Zaslow added that the owner who is shut out can recover his share of the value of the use of the land from the time of the ouster.
Today, Civil Code section 843 turns Carpentier’s demand into a formal procedure. A co-owner out of possession serves a written demand for shared possession, and if the co-owner in possession does not offer it within 60 days, an ouster is established.
What Carpentier Means for California Co-Owners
- No one owns “the back half.” A co-owner who claims a unit, a building, or a fenced area as theirs alone is claiming something the law does not give them. As Johns v. Scobie later put it, each co-owner may occupy the whole property.
- Ask to be let in, in writing. A clear demand followed by a refusal is what made the ouster in Carpentier, and it is what Civil Code section 843 requires today. The same applies when a co-owner changes the locks without your permission.
- An ouster means money. The shut-out owner can claim rental value for the part they were kept out of, credited in the partition accounting.
- Don’t let an ouster sit. An ouster can start the clock on a claim of adverse possession between co-owners.
- Partition is how each owner gets their own. Webster had built on the land he fenced, and a co-owner can be credited for improvements in a partition. Code of Civil Procedure section 873.220 (CCP 873.220) is the lawful way to keep that kind of work: in a partition in kind, CCP 873.220’s rule on allotting improvements lets the court give an owner the part they improved if that does not harm the others. When the property can’t be fairly divided, it is sold and the proceeds are split.
Co-Owner Claiming Part of the Property as Theirs? End It With a Partition
If a co-owner has taken over part of a property you own together and won’t share it, a partition action ends the co-ownership and settles what you are owed for the use you lost. Your co-owner cannot stop it, because the right to partition is absolute unless it was waived.
Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from proving your right to partition through the partition sale and the final division of proceeds. No fees until you win. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online for a free consultation.








