A partition sale is not final when the partition referee accepts the winning bid. The sale goes back to the court for confirmation, and at that hearing a new bidder can still step in. In Parker v. Owen (1950) 96 Cal.App.2d 78, the California Court of Appeal held that a judge may accept a written bid at least 10 percent higher than the referee’s sale price, even when nothing was wrong with the original sale and the price was not too low. Getting the highest price, the court said, helps every co-owner.
Why Parker v. Owen Matters
- The winning bid is not the last word. Until the court confirms the sale, a higher written offer at the hearing can take the property.
- No unfairness is needed. The overbid does not require proof that the sale was unfair or that the price was inadequate.
- The judge decides. Accepting the overbid is within the trial court’s discretion.
- The rule lives on in today’s statute. Code of Civil Procedure section 873.740 (CCP 873.740, the increased-offer rule) carries the same rule forward with an updated formula.
The Facts: Two Sisters and Four Parcels
Gladys L. Parker filed a partition action in Los Angeles County Superior Court against her sister, Margaret M. Owen, over nine parcels of real estate and two bank accounts that had belonged to their mother. Both the mother and Gladys died while the case was pending, and the case went on in Gladys’s name. The case was dismissed as to five parcels. The trial court found that the sisters each owned half of the remaining four parcels and that those parcels could not be divided without great prejudice to the owners. It entered an interlocutory judgment appointing referees to sell the four parcels, and both sides were allowed to bid.
At the referees’ sale, Owen bought three parcels for $8,750, $10,250 and $18,250. Wm. R. Parker, as a successor to Gladys’s interest, bought the fourth for $35,000. Every sale was subject to the court’s confirmation.
At the confirmation hearing, the court asked for further bids in open court. Over Owen’s objection, two written offers came in, each 10 percent higher than Owen’s price on one of her parcels: $9,625 from Wm. R. Parker as president of Parker Construction Company, and $11,275 from Wm. R. Parker individually and as trustee, as successors in interest of Gladys. No one bid higher. The court confirmed those two parcels to the Parker bidders and confirmed the other two sales as made. Owen appealed.
How the Court of Appeal Decided the Case
The Statute in 1950
The case turned on former Code of Civil Procedure section 784. One sentence of that section let the court vacate a sale and order a new one if the proceedings were unfair or the price was disproportionate to the value. The last sentence added a separate path:
“If an offer of ten per cent more in amount than that named in the return be made to the court, in writing, by a responsible person, it is in the discretion of the court to accept such offer and confirm the sale to such person, or to order a new sale.”
Parker v. Owen (1950) 96 Cal.App.2d 78, 80 (quoting former Code of Civil Procedure section 784)
Owen argued that the two sentences had to be read together, so a court could accept a higher bid only if the sale had been unfair or the price inadequate.
The Overbid Path Stands on Its Own
No appellate court had yet interpreted this part of section 784, so the court looked to decisions on a similarly worded probate sale statute, former Probate Code section 785. Following Estate of Bradley (1914) 168 Cal. 655 and Estate of Naftzger (1944) 24 Cal.2d 595, it held that the statute was clear and must be read as written. The court explained:
“There is nothing in the language of the section which would indicate an intention to impose upon the procedure outlined in its last sentence the conditions of unfairness and inadequacy of price recited in the foregoing sentence.”
Parker v. Owen (1950) 96 Cal.App.2d 78, 82
The Highest Price Helps Every Co-Owner
The court added a practical reason. In a partition by sale, every owner shares in the proceeds, so a higher price is good for all of them:
“[W]hen a sale is ordered in a partition action, it is to the mutual advantage of both parties to get the highest price available in the market, and it is within the sound discretion of the trial judge to accept a higher bid when offered at the hearing for confirmation.”
Parker v. Owen (1950) 96 Cal.App.2d 78, 82
The Result
The Court of Appeal affirmed the order confirming the sale of the two parcels to the higher bidders.
The Law Today: Overbids Under CCP 873.740
California rewrote its partition statutes in 1976. The Law Revision Commission comment to CCP 873.740 says it supersedes the last sentence of former section 784, the sentence construed in Parker. The rule is the same, with a new formula:
“If at the hearing under Section 873.730 a responsible bidder makes a written increased offer that exceeds the sale price by at least 10 percent on the first ten thousand dollars ($10,000) and 5 percent on the amount in excess thereof, the court in its discretion may do either of the following:”
CCP 873.740, subdivision (a)
The court may then order a new sale, or accept the higher offer and confirm the sale to that bidder. On a $500,000 sale, for example, a qualifying overbid must be at least $525,500: $1,000 on the first $10,000 plus $24,500 on the remaining $490,000. Unless the court ordered otherwise before the sale, or the parties agreed otherwise, the overbid is measured by its gross amount, including any agent’s commission on it.
The hearing itself is set by a motion under CCP 873.720, the motion to confirm or set aside a sale, and CCP 873.730’s grounds for vacating a partition sale are separate, such as unfair proceedings or a price disproportionate to the value. As Parker held under the old statute, the overbid path does not depend on those grounds.
In cases under the Partition of Real Property Act, most sales are open-market listings by a court-appointed broker under CCP 874.320’s open-market sale rule. When the court orders an auction instead, it is conducted under the referee-sale procedures that begin at CCP 873.510.
What Parker v. Owen Means for California Co-Owners
- Plan for the confirmation hearing. A co-owner who wants a particular property should be ready to bid again at the hearing.
- Put it in writing. The overbid must be a written offer by a responsible bidder.
- A fair sale can still be topped. Unlike a price objection, which needs real proof of value (as Dunn v. Dunn shows), an overbid needs only a qualifying higher offer.
- Higher prices help the co-owner who wants out. For the co-owner who filed to get their money out of the property, an overbid means more proceeds to divide. See whether a partition sale yields fair market value.
Ready to Get Your Co-Owned Property Sold?
Parker v. Owen shows that a California partition sale is built to bring the highest price. If you want to force the sale of a property you co-own, a partition attorney can guide you through the referee’s sale, the confirmation hearing and closing.
Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from the complaint through the referee’s sale and the final distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.







