A long-term lease and purchase option can, in unusual facts, stand in the way of a partition. In Penasquitos, Inc. v. Holladay (1972) 27 Cal.App.3d 356 (“Penasquitos“), the Court of Appeal denied partition of land in San Diego because two brothers who owned it as tenants in common had given a developer a 99-year lease and an option to buy, and the court found those contracts implied an agreement not to partition. The co-owner asking for partition was the developer’s own company, which held the lease and the option.
Penasquitos is also the source of a phrase that co-owners still try to use against a partition: that the right to partition “is subject to the requirement of fairness.” That sentence was written under the law in effect before 1976. Today, Code of Civil Procedure section 872.710 (CCP 872.710) provides that partition “shall be as of right unless barred by a valid waiver.” There is no fairness exception, and California courts have since made clear that fairness is not a defense to partition.
Why Penasquitos v. Holladay Matters
- It is a waiver case, not a fairness case. The court denied partition because the lease and option implied an agreement not to partition, not because a sale seemed unfair.
- The co-owner seeking partition was also the tenant and option holder. A partition would have let it get the property without paying the purchase price it had agreed to.
- Its “requirement of fairness” sentence predates the 1976 Partition Law. American Medical International v. Feller repeated it in 1976, and the Court of Appeal has since said that case does not guide the analysis under CCP 872.710’s right to partition.
- Ordinary co-owners rarely have anything like this deal. Siblings who inherit a house, exes on title, and friends who bought together almost never sign a 99-year lease and option with an outside developer.
The Facts: Two Brothers, a 99-Year Lease and an Option to Buy
In July 1962, Jim and Robert Holladay owned land in San Diego as tenants in common. They gave Irvin Kahn a 99-year lease of the 5.86 usable acres, with minimum rent of $1,800 a year per acre plus 8 percent of the gross revenue from improvements and activities over $131,850. The lease came with an option to buy the property at $60,000 per usable acre, in pieces of one acre or more at a time. Kahn later became president and majority shareholder of Penasquitos, Inc., and assigned the lease and option to it. (Penasquitos, at p. 357.)
In October 1968, Robert sold his 40 percent interest to Penasquitos for $65,000. Jim offered to sell his interest at the option price. Penasquitos instead offered him the market value of his interest, subject to its own lease and option, and Jim said no. Penasquitos then sued for partition by sale, saying a sale would preserve the property’s commercial value. (Penasquitos, at p. 358.)
The trial court ordered a physical division of the land, called partition in kind. Its September 1971 interlocutory judgment also confirmed that Penasquitos’ lease and option were valid. Jim appealed.
How the Court of Appeal Decided the Case
An Implied Agreement Not to Partition
Nothing in the lease or option said the brothers gave up partition. As the court put it, “Any waiver would have to be by implication as none is expressly written into the contract documents.” (Penasquitos, at p. 358.) Reading the contracts as a whole, the court found they were built so that both brothers would share in rent or in the purchase price according to their interests, wherever on the land development took place. Dividing the land would let the developer favor one brother over the other, and Penasquitos had already bought Robert’s share.
The court held: “Where the effect of a cotenancy partition is to substantially impair contractually acquired joint rights, an agreement not to partition is implicit in the agreement.” (Penasquitos, at p. 359.) Penasquitos, as the buyer of Robert’s interest, was bound by that implied agreement.
A Sale Would Not Fix the Problem
The court also rejected a partition sale. Because the land was burdened by Penasquitos’ own lease and option, a buyer would pay much less than the option price. In the court’s words, a sale would “substitute a market value for the remainder interest, depressed by the lease and option agreements, for the option price agreed upon by the parties to the agreements.” (Penasquitos, at p. 359.)
The Result
The court concluded that “the only way to preserve the reasonable expectations of Jim Holladay under the contracts to which the property is subject is to deny partition.” (Penasquitos, at p. 359.) It reversed the judgment. It also rejected Jim’s separate argument that Penasquitos lost its option by buying Robert’s share for less than the option price, because he cited no authority for it.
Why the “Requirement of Fairness” Line Is Not the Law Today
Before reaching the contracts, the court wrote one sentence of background:
“Although partition is a matter of right when a cotenant desires it (De Roulet v. Mitchel, 70 Cal.App.2d 120 [160 P.2d 574]), it is subject to the requirement of fairness and the right may be waived by contract, either expressly or by implication.”
Penasquitos, Inc. v. Holladay (1972) 27 Cal.App.3d 356, 358
The case it cited for the right to partition, De Roulet v. Mitchel (1945) 70 Cal.App.2d 120, 124, said that “in no event is a partition to be denied because it will result in financial loss to the cotenants.” For the rest of the sentence, the court cited Pine v. Tiedt (1965) 232 Cal.App.2d 733, another case decided under the old statute. And the result in Penasquitos rested on waiver, not on fairness.
In 1976, American Medical International, Inc. v. Feller (1976) 59 Cal.App.3d 1008 cited Penasquitos to describe a “requirement of fairness.” That same year, the Legislature enacted the current California partition statutes. Under CCP 872.710(b), “partition as to concurrent interests in the property shall be as of right unless barred by a valid waiver.” The statute says nothing about fairness. The Court of Appeal has said of the 1976 case: “Because AMI does not address section 872.710, it does not guide our analysis.” (Caiozzo v. 2672 to 2674 North Beachwood Drive, LLC (Nov. 13, 2023, B322219) 2023 WL 7485496, at p. *6 [nonpub. opn.].) Our article on why fairness is not a defense to partition covers the full line of cases.
Fairness still has a place, just not in deciding whether a co-owner gets partition. Once the right is established, the court weighs whether a sale or a division is more equitable under CCP 872.820’s rule on sale instead of division.
The Part That Survives: Waiver by Agreement
The 1976 statute kept one defense: a valid waiver. In LEG Investments v. Boxler (2010) 183 Cal.App.4th 484, 493, the Court of Appeal wrote that “A co-owner of property has an absolute right to partition unless barred by a valid waiver.” Penasquitos shows how narrow that is. The waiver came from detailed contracts with an outside developer that tied rent and the purchase price to each brother’s share, and the co-owner who sued was the developer’s own company trying to use partition to get around those contracts.
What Penasquitos Means for California Co-Owners
- “A sale would be unfair to me” is not a defense. Under CCP 872.710(b), a co-owner has an absolute right to partition unless a valid waiver bars it. Courts have rejected the fairness defense under the current statute.
- Check the date on any case your co-owner cites. Penasquitos was decided in 1972, four years before the current partition statutes.
- A waiver needs a real agreement that conflicts with partition. In Penasquitos, it took a 99-year lease and a purchase option tied to each owner’s share.
- Partition is not a way around your own contract. A co-owner who has agreed to buy at a set price cannot use a partition sale to pay less.
Is Your Co-Owner Citing Penasquitos? Enforce Your Right to Partition
If your co-owner says a court can stop a sale because it would be unfair, that argument relies on language written before the current law, and fairness is not a defense to partition today. A partition action is how a California co-owner ends the co-ownership, and the right to file one does not depend on what your co-owner thinks is fair.
Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from proving your right to partition through the sale and the final distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online for a free 30-minute consultation.







