Co-owners sometimes act as if they own a particular corner of the property outright. One of them signs a deed selling a specific lot, or grants a strip for a road or a rail line, without the others joining in. When a partition action follows, the co-owners who never signed want to know whether those side deals change what they get. In East Shore Co. v. Richmond Belt Railway (1916) 172 Cal. 174, the California Supreme Court held that they do not. The whole tract is still partitioned as if the deed had never been made, and the buyer’s piece comes out of the seller’s share only if that can be done without hurting the other co-owners.
The court also confirmed that co-owned land is presumed capable of being divided, and that the co-owner who wants a sale instead has to prove the case for one.
Why East Shore Matters
- A side deed binds only the co-owner who signed it. A deed of a specific piece conveys only that co-owner’s interest in it. It does not cut the piece out of the property as far as the other co-owners are concerned.
- The buyer’s piece comes out of the seller’s share. The court sets the conveyed piece apart to the buyer and charges it against the selling co-owner, but only when that can be done “without material injury to the rights and interests of the other cotenants.”
- One co-owner cannot burden the others with an easement. A right of way granted by one owner is good only against that owner’s interest.
- The co-owner who wants a sale carries the burden. Division is presumed possible. A sale requires evidence.
The Facts: Tideland Lots, a Rail Line, and Deeds the Other Owners Never Signed
The case came out of Contra Costa County, where several owners held a series of tideland lots as tenants in common. Before the lawsuit, one co-owner, the East Shore Company, deeded strips of the land to the Richmond Belt Railway “as and for a right of way” for a railroad. While the case was pending, some of the co-owners signed deeds that purported to convey other specific parcels outright to third parties.
The trial court took proof of those deeds, found that the land could be divided without material injury to the owners, and entered an interlocutory judgment appointing three partition referees to divide it. Each conveyed parcel was to be charged against the share of the co-owner who deeded it and set apart to the buyer, provided that could be done without material injury to the co-owners who had not joined in the deed.
One co-owner, J. Goodwin Thompson, had signed none of the deeds. He appealed, arguing that the deeds had been handled wrongly and that the land should have been sold instead of divided.
How the Supreme Court Decided the Case
The Deed Did Not Carve the Parcel Out of the Property
The court relied on a rule it had stated decades earlier in Gates v. Salmon (1868) 35 Cal. 576. A buyer from one co-owner gets only what that co-owner had: an interest in the parcel shared with everyone else, held at the risk that the parcel will be allotted to someone else in a partition. As the court put it:
“[H]is conveyance did not sever the special tract from the general tract, so far as the cotenants are concerned, and the general tract is therefore liable to a partition so far as the cotenants of the grantor are concerned, as it would be had the conveyance of the special tract not been made.”
East Shore Co. v. Richmond Belt Railway (1916) 172 Cal. 174, 177-178
Because Thompson’s share could not be harmed by how the court sorted things out between the selling co-owners and their buyers, he had no ground to complain about those rulings. For the same reason, it did not matter whether the railway’s deed conveyed full title or only an easement. Either way, it affected only the East Shore Company’s interest.
The court traced the buyer’s protection to Emeric v. Alvarado (1891) 90 Cal. 444, which treated partition as an equitable proceeding in which a buyer may receive the specific tract when the other co-owners are not injured. Today, Code of Civil Procedure section 873.230 carries that rule forward for deeds signed before the partition action is filed. The property is divided so as to allot the conveyed portion to the buyer “to the extent it can be done without material injury to the rights of the other parties.”
A Buyer’s Convenience Does Not Override the Other Co-Owners
The trial court had found that some of the buyers owned neighboring land and that the parcels they bought were convenient to it. The Supreme Court said those facts should play no part in the division. A buyer’s ownership of the land next door “cannot justify the allotment thereof to him, if to do so would in fact materially injure another tenant in common.”
The Co-Owner Who Wants a Sale Must Prove It
Thompson argued the lots could not be fairly divided because some were worth more than others for reaching navigable water. The court answered that referees can account for differences in value, and it restated the starting point: “The presumption is that land held in common tenancy can be equitably divided between the parties by allotting to each a tract in severalty, equal to his interest in the whole, measured by value.” Under Mitchell v. Cline (1890) 84 Cal. 418, the burden of showing otherwise rested on Thompson, and he had not met it.
That framework is still the law. Code of Civil Procedure section 872.810 makes a partition in kind the default, and Code of Civil Procedure section 872.820 calls for a partition by sale when the parties agree or when a sale would be “more equitable than division of the property.” Courts still cite East Shore for the burden of proof, including in Richmond v. Dofflemyer and Butte Creek Island Ranch v. Crim.
The Result
The interlocutory judgment was affirmed. The referees were to divide the land, with each conveyed parcel coming out of the share of the co-owner who deeded it.
What East Shore Means for California Co-Owners
- Your co-owner’s side deal does not come out of your share. A deed, right of way, or lease signed by one owner reaches only that owner’s interest. Swartzbaugh v. Sampson applies the same idea to a lease signed by one co-owner.
- You can still partition the whole property. A co-owner who sells off a piece does not shrink what the court can divide or sell, and does not limit your right to partition.
- A buyer of one piece is protected only so far. The buyer receives that piece only if the other co-owners still come out whole.
- If you want a sale, bring evidence. A single house usually cannot be split, so that showing is simple. For acreage or a group of lots, expect to prove why a sale is fairer than a division.
Co-Owner Deeded Away Part of the Property? You Can Still Partition
East Shore shows that one co-owner’s deal with an outsider does not take away the other owners’ rights. If your co-owner has sold, leased, or granted rights in part of your property without you, have a partition attorney look at what it means for your share.
Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from the complaint through the referee’s sale or division and the final distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.







