One of the most common disputes in a partition action arises when the co-owner in sole possession has also been paying all of the expenses. That co-owner often believes that they will collect all of their expenses in an accounting in a partition action. Effectively, the issue is whether the co-owner out of possession can claim the rental value of the co-owned property against the co-owner in possession. In California, the answer is often yes, but only as a defense: the court may subtract that rental value from the expenses the co-owner in possession asks to recover. The court’s power to make these compensatory adjustments is also the subject of Code of Civil Procedure section 872.140 (CCP 872.140).
The Rule From Hunter v. Schultz
The rule comes from Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 31–32. The Court of Appeal adopted a rule stated in an American Law Reports annotation: “when, in a suit for partition or a sale for division, or other proceeding between cotenants in equity or in which equitable powers may be exerted, a cotenant who has been in possession or use of the premises seeks to obtain contribution respecting improvements made, or amounts expended in protection or preservation of the property, the court, as incidental to the granting of such relief and by way of adjusting the rights of the parties, may charge the claimant, defensively, with at least a part of the reasonable value of his occupancy or use ….”[1] The court found the rule “sound, just and consonant with equitable principles.”[2]
How the Court Applied the Rule in Hunter
The facts show how the offset works. Ann Hunter and Melvin Schultz acquired a San Leandro house as joint tenants in 1950. After they separated in 1952, Ann moved out and never lived there again. “After her departure, she paid nothing on the mortgages, taxes, insurance, repairs or improvements on the property.” Melvin stayed, and after he remarried, he and his new wife, Hildegard, lived in, maintained, and improved the house. A decade after Ann moved out, she filed a partition action.
The trial court ordered the house sold. It reimbursed Melvin and Hildegard for the loan principal they paid ($3,380) and for improvements ($1,862.10), but it did not credit the $6,257.86 they paid for interest, taxes, and insurance. The trial court found that this amount was offset by “the value of the use of plaintiff’s interest in the property.” Hildegard appealed, arguing that Ann had been given a “rental allowance” even though no one had ever paid rent. The Court of Appeal disagreed that the offset was rent, and it affirmed.[3]
What the Treatises Say
As the leading treatise on California real estate law, Miller & Starr, explains:
Right of cotenant not in possession to offset against claims by the cotenant in possession. When one cotenant has exclusive possession of the cotenancy property, the rental value of the premises may be offset by the cotenant out of possession against the claims of the cotenant in possession for contribution for interest, taxes, insurance, and loan obligations paid.[4]
Witkin Summary of California Law explains Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 31–32 as follows: “If the occupying cotenant seeks reimbursement for payment of interest, taxes, and insurance, the tenant out of possession is entitled to offset the reimbursement by the reasonable value of the occupant’s use.” [5]
California Jurisprudence explains the rule from Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 31–32 as follows:
Although, in the absence of an agreement between them, one cotenant has no right against another cotenant in exclusive possession of the premises to recover the rental value of the premises for the occupancy and use, in a partition suit brought by a cotenant not in possession, an offset for the value of the use of the plaintiff’s interest may properly be allowed against the interest, taxes, and insurance paid by the defendant cotenants in possession.[6]
American Law Reports cites Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24 as “holding or recognizing that cotenant in possession claiming contribution is chargeable with rents or profits.”[7]
American Jurisprudence cites Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24 as “offsetting reasonable value of use of plaintiff’s interest against payments by defendants for interest, taxes, and insurance.” Accountability in equitable proceedings, 20 Am. Jur. 2d Cotenancy and Joint Ownership (Nov. 2022) § 50, n. 3.
Courts Still Apply the Rule
The rule is still the law today. The 1995 bankruptcy court opinion in In re Fazzio (Bankr. E.D. Cal. 1995) 180 B.R. 263, 269, quotes Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 31–32.
An unpublished 2021 case in California described Hunter as finding that “in a partition action, where a cotenant in possession seeks contribution for improvements made or amounts expended to protect or preserve the property, the court may award the out-of-possession cotenant the reasonable value of the other’s use of the property as an offset.”[8]
An unpublished 2016 decision found that: “A cotenant out of possession may be entitled to the imputed rental value as an offset to a claim for contribution for the maintenance and preservation of the property if doing so would be ‘just and consonant with equitable principles.’ (Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 32.” [9]
The Three Exceptions to the Rule Against Charging Rent
An unpublished 2014 decision explained that Hunter represents one of three exceptions to the general rule that “a cotenant out of possession of real property has no right against another cotenant in exclusive possession of the property to recover rental value for occupancy and use of the property, because each cotenant has the right to occupy the property.” The three exceptions are:[10]
- an agreement between the cotenants to share rents and profits;
- ouster of the cotenant out of possession; and
- a demand by the cotenant in possession for contribution toward expenditures for the cotenancy, in which case the court, as a matter of equity, may award the cotenant out of possession the reasonable value of the other cotenant’s use of the property as an offset. This third exception is the rule from Hunter.
A 2013 unpublished case found that rental value can be claimed defensively even though under-market rent was being paid, finding that: “The fact that cross-complainants did not require David and Nancy to pay greater rent for the property during their co-ownership of the property does not defeat their claim for an offset.”[11] Indeed, in that case, the Court of Appeal found that “the trial court abused its discretion by failing to reduce the award of reimbursement for capital improvements by the difference between the amount David and Nancy actually paid in rent and the reasonable value of their occupancy or use of the property – which was established by the evidence.”
Other States Follow the Same Rule
A 2010 decision from Hawaii agreed with the holding in Hunter. The Hawaii court held that “a court in equity, in a partition action not involving ouster or agreement, has the discretionary authority to allow an apportioned defensive rental offset against maintenance-related and improvement-related contributions, to the extent that the ‘reasonable rental value of the use of the property by the [cotenant in possession] … has exceeded his or her proportionate share of ownership,’” because “He who seeks equity must do equity.”[12] The court explained: “The apportioned rental offset exception is the counterpart of the equity that the court exercises in allowing the [cotenant in possession] credit for unreimbursed maintenance and improvement expenditures…. The analysis focuses on whether one cotenant has a disproportionate share of the benefits or the burdens. An offset could be warranted because if one cotenant enjoys a disproportionate share of the benefits, the other cotenants must be compensated.”
The Bottom Line
The bottom line is that co-owners out of possession have rights in a partition accounting to ensure an equitable result. A co-owner who has paid the mortgage, taxes, and insurance while living in the property should expect the other side to ask the court to subtract the rental value of the home from those payments.
Talkov Law Partition Attorneys Can Help
A co-owner who lives in the property and pays its expenses does not get to ignore the value of that occupancy. Whether you are the co-owner in possession or the co-owner out of possession, the accounting in a partition action decides who is owed what.
Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step of the process, including the accounting for rental value, mortgage payments, taxes, and improvements. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.
References
| ↑1 | Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 31 (quoting Accountability of cotenants for rents and profits or use and occupation, 51 A.L.R.2d 388, 454) (italics added by the Hunter court). |
|---|---|
| ↑2 | Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 32. |
| ↑3 | Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 26–27, 30–32. |
| ↑4 | Right to lease or license to a third person—Recovery of rental value or profits from cotenant in sole possession, 4 Cal. Real Est. § 11:4 (4th ed.) (citing Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 30). Miller & Starr also explains that: “Even though a cotenant who is not in possession cannot collect the rental value from the tenant in possession, on partition, the court can offset the rental value against the claim by the cotenant in possession for amounts advanced for interest, taxes, and insurance premiums before distribution of the sale proceeds.” § 11:18. Right of partition—Decree of partition, 4 Cal. Real Est. § 11:18 (4th ed.) (citing Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 30); accord Siron v. Valdez (Cal. Ct. App. Dec. 11, 2006) No. B186158, 2006 WL 3579709, at *4 (quoting Miller & Starr). |
| ↑5 | Accounting for Rents and Profits, 12 Witkin, Summary 11th Real Prop (2022) § 48. |
| ↑6 | 48 Cal. Jur. 3d Partition (Nov. 2022) § 15. California Jurisprudence also cites Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 31–32 in finding that “a cotenant in possession or use of the premises who seeks an allowance for improvement of the property may be charged with at least a part of the reasonable value of that cotenant’s occupancy or use though that cotenant could not otherwise be required to account for those benefits.” 48 Cal. Jur. 3d Partition (Nov. 2022) § 16. |
| ↑7 | Accountability of cotenants for rents and profits or use and occupation, 51 A.L.R.2d 388. |
| ↑8 | Hofmann v. Hofmann (Cal. Ct. App. July 15, 2021) No. F079977, 2021 WL 2980582, at *20. |
| ↑9 | In re Marriage of Stone (Cal. Ct. App. May 9, 2016) No. B243240, 2016 WL 2756882, at *8. |
| ↑10 | Rodman v. Blake, No. D061434, 2014 WL 4238982, at *11 (Cal. Ct. App. Aug. 27, 2014) (citing Teixeira v. Verissimo (1966) 239 Cal.App.2d 147, 155, and Brunscher v. Reagh (1958) 164 Cal.App.2d 174, 176–177). Rodman explained that “there are three exceptions to the general rule: (1) where there is an agreement between the cotenants to share rents and profits (Teixeira, supra, 239 Cal.App.2d at p. 155; Black v. Black (1949) 91 Cal.App.2d 328, 332); (2) where the cotenant in possession has ousted the cotenant out of possession (Estate of Hughes, supra, 5 Cal.App.4th 1607, 1611; Teixeira, supra, 239 Cal.App.2d at p. 155); or (3) where the cotenant in possession demands contribution for expenditures on behalf of the cotenancy, the court, as a matter of equity, may award the cotenant out of possession the reasonable value of the other cotenant’s use of the property as an offset against the contribution for expenditures. (Hunter, supra, 240 Cal.App.2d at pp. 31–32; In re Fazzio (Bnkr.E.D.Cal.1995) 180 B.R. 263, 269.)” The three exceptions are also explained in the unpublished decision of DeMartini v. DeMartini (Cal. Ct. App. June 28, 2013) No. A133277, 2013 WL 3287991, at *6, Coulter v. McNeil (Cal. Ct. App. July 28, 2011) No. B219538, 2011 WL 3211101, at *3, and Koefoed v. Camejo (Cal. Ct. App. July 30, 2007) No. B188429, 2007 WL 2165372, at *3, as modified on denial of reh’g (Aug. 28, 2007). |
| ↑11 | DeMartini v. DeMartini (Cal. Ct. App. June 28, 2013) No. A133277, 2013 WL 3287991, at *6. |
| ↑12 | Curtis v. Dorn (Haw. Ct. App. 2010) 123 Haw. 301, 310, 234 P.3d 683, 692 (citations and internal quotation marks omitted). |







