California Code of Civil Procedure § 872.420 – Lien Claims in a Partition Answer

CCP 872.420 requires a lienholder’s answer in a partition action to state the date, type, and unpaid amount of its lien.

CCP 872.420 Code of Civil Procedure, lien claims in a partition answer, lien date and amount, California: lien claim documents beside mortgage papers and a model house

California Code of Civil Procedure section 872.420 (CCP 872.420) tells a lender or other lienholder named in a partition action what its answer to the partition complaint must say: the date of the lien, what kind of lien it is, and how much is still owed. It adds to the general requirements for every answer in CCP 872.410 and is part of the California partition statutes.

Full Text of CCP 872.420

Where the defendant has or claims a lien on the property, the answer shall set forth the date and character of the lien and the amount remaining due thereon.

California Code of Civil Procedure section 872.420 (added by Statutes 1976, chapter 73)

What CCP 872.420 Requires in Plain English

Many co-owned homes carry a mortgage, a home equity line, or a judgment lien. Because the plaintiff must join everyone with a recorded interest under CCP 872.510, lenders and other lienholders are often defendants. Section 872.420 tells them what to put in the answer:

  • The date of the lien, such as the date the deed of trust was recorded.
  • The character of the lien, such as a deed of trust, a mechanic’s lien, a tax lien, or a judgment lien.
  • The amount remaining due, meaning the unpaid balance on the date of the answer.

This tells the court and the co-owners how much of the property’s value is spoken for before anyone receives a share. It matters most in a partition by sale, because CCP 873.820 pays liens from the sale proceeds after the expenses of sale and the other costs of partition, and before the rest is distributed to the owners.

The Law Revision Commission Comment on CCP 872.420

The California Law Revision Commission recommended the partition statutes that the Legislature enacted in 1976. Its comment on section 872.420 reads:

Section 872.420 continues a portion of former Section 758. The provision for waiver for failure to disclose additional security formerly found in Section 758 is omitted because it was unduly harsh. It should be noted that nothing in Section 872.420 precludes the defendant from alleging such additional costs, fees, and expenses related to the lien as he may be entitled to in addition to the amount remaining due on the lien itself.

California Law Revision Commission Comment to Code of Civil Procedure section 872.420 (1976)

The comment makes two points. First, the old law, former section 758, punished a lienholder who failed to disclose additional security for the debt by treating that security as waived; the Commission dropped that rule as “unduly harsh.” Second, a lienholder may claim more than the bare balance, such as the costs, fees, and expenses its loan documents allow, as long as it pleads them.

How California Courts Have Applied CCP 872.420

Section 872.420 carries forward part of former section 758. In Stewart v. Abernathy (1944) 62 Cal.App.2d 429, 432–433, the Court of Appeal described former section 758 as requiring a lienholder to “state the date and character of the lien, the amount remaining due, and whether he has any additional security therefor,” and held that “This section is mandatory.” The court also held that the lender’s attorney’s fees were not a cost of partition, because its lawyer “performed no services which were for the common benefit” of the owners.

The Court of Appeal applied the same rule under the current statutes in Stutz v. Davis (1981) 122 Cal.App.3d 1, 6. Two lienholders were named as defendants, and the court held that they could not recover attorney’s fees as costs of partition under CCP 874.010. Their remedy was the fee clause in their deed of trust. Our guide to attorney’s fees in a partition action explains the common benefit rule.

Where CCP 872.420 Fits in the California Partition Statutes

Section 872.420 is the second of three sections in the “Answer” article. It follows CCP 872.410, which lists what every answer must contain, and comes before CCP 872.430, under which “The answer may set forth any claim the defendant has for contribution or other compensatory adjustment.”

Later in the case, the court can decide disputes over liens under CCP 872.630 on the status and priority of liens. After a sale, CCP 873.810 governs the court’s order disbursing the proceeds, and CCP 873.820 sets the order of payment.

Common Questions About Liens in a Partition Action

Does My Lender Have to Be Named in the Partition Action?

Usually yes, because a recorded deed of trust is an interest in the property, and CCP 872.510 requires the plaintiff to join those with recorded interests. Naming the lender lets the court sell the property and pay off the loan from the proceeds so the buyer takes clear title.

Does a Partition Sale Pay Off the Mortgage?

Yes, unless the terms of sale leave the lien on the property. Under CCP 873.820, liens are paid in their order of priority before the owners receive their shares. Our post on mortgage assumptions in partition actions covers the cases where a buyer takes over the loan instead.

Who Gets Credit for Paying Down the Mortgage?

A co-owner who paid more than a fair share of the mortgage can ask for a credit in the accounting between the co-owners, raised in the answer under CCP 872.430. Our guide to proving mortgage payments in a partition action covers the records needed, and our overview of partition offsets and accounting explains how the credits are calculated.

Get Help With Liens in a California Partition

A lien that is misstated or overlooked can delay a sale or shrink your share. Getting the numbers right in the pleadings protects your equity.

Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step of the process, from the pleadings through the sale, the payoff of liens, and the final distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.

Related partition content

Categories: Filing for Partition, Finance, Liens & Bankruptcy

Topics: ,

Statutes: , , , , ,

Cases: ,

Scott Talkov

About Scott Talkov

Scott Talkov founded Talkov Law, the first and largest law firm in the United States dedicated exclusively to partition actions. He oversees a team of 12 partition attorneys. He has handled more than 650 partition cases in 41 California counties, resolving over $400 million in co-owned real estate with zero partitions denied. He has been repeatedly selected to Super Lawyers, including the 2027 list.