Grothe v. Cortlandt Corp.: A Co-Owner’s Judgment Lien Dies With Him in a Joint Tenancy

In Grothe v. Cortlandt Corp., the Court of Appeal held that a levy without a sale does not sever a joint tenancy, so the lien died with the debtor co-owner.

In Grothe v. Cortlandt Corp., the California Court of Appeal held that a sheriff's levy without an execution sale does not sever a joint tenancy, so the surviving joint tenant took the property free of her deceased co-owner's judgment creditor.

If you own property in joint tenancy with someone who owes money on a court judgment, what happens to the creditor’s lien when that co-owner dies? In Grothe v. Cortlandt Corp. (1992) 11 Cal.App.4th 1313, the Court of Appeal held that the lien dies with the debtor. A recorded sheriff’s levy that has not yet led to a sale does not sever the joint tenancy, so the surviving joint tenant takes the whole property free of the deceased co-owner’s judgment creditor. For partition attorneys and their clients, the case shows how title can decide whether a co-owner’s debts follow the property into a partition action.

The court upheld an injunction that stopped the creditor from selling the property.

Why Grothe v. Cortlandt Corp. Matters

  1. Survivorship is automatic. “[W]hen one joint tenant dies, the entire estate belongs automatically to the surviving joint tenant(s).”
  2. A lien is not a severance. “[T]he mere imposition of a lien or encumbrance does not sever the joint tenancy.”
  3. Only a completed sale severs. A creditor’s levy just marks the property for a later sale. Title and possession do not change until the execution sale happens.
  4. The case lists what does sever. A voluntary transfer, a judgment in partition and an execution sale each end a joint tenancy. A pending partition case does not.

The Facts: A Levy Recorded Three Months Before the Co-Owner Died

In 1983, Laurene Grothe and David Ribis bought real property in Riverside County as joint tenants. In 1987, creditors obtained default judgments against both of them. Grothe had the judgment against her set aside. The judgment against Ribis stayed in place.

The creditors assigned the judgment to Cortlandt Corporation in March 1990. In July 1990, the Riverside County Sheriff recorded a notice of levy against the property. Ribis died in October 1990, before the 120-day waiting period that must pass before a sale had run out.

Grothe, believing she owned the property as the surviving joint tenant, filed an affidavit of death of joint tenant. During an escrow, she learned of the lien and levy for the first time. When the property was noticed for sale in March 1991, she obtained a temporary restraining order and then a preliminary injunction. The creditor appealed.

How the Court of Appeal Decided the Case

The Survivor Takes Under the Deed, Not From the Deceased Owner

The court started with how the right of survivorship works:

“Nothing ‘passes’ from the deceased joint tenant to the survivor; rather, the survivor takes from the instrument by which the joint tenancy was created.”

Grothe v. Cortlandt Corp. (1992) 11 Cal.App.4th 1313, 1317

Because the survivor’s right was fixed when the joint tenancy was created, the survivor takes nothing from the deceased owner or from that owner’s creditor.

A Lien or Levy Does Not Sever the Joint Tenancy

A joint tenancy is severed when one of its four unities is destroyed. A sale to a third party does that, whether the sale is voluntary or forced, and the buyer becomes a tenant in common. A lien does not. Quoting the California Supreme Court’s decision in Tenhet v. Boswell (1976) 18 Cal.3d 150, the court explained that “when such a joint tenant dies his interest dies with him, and any encumbrances placed by him on the property become unenforceable against the surviving joint tenant.” (Grothe, at p. 1318.)

The creditor argued that a levy is different because the sheriff has seized the property. The court disagreed. A levy on real property is merely “the act by which property to be taken and sold is designated or set aside,” and “the sheriff’s levy does not effect a change in title or right to possession up to the moment of sale.” (Grothe, at pp. 1320–1321.)

The Creditor Took the Risk by Waiting

The court relied on Zeigler v. Bonnell (1942) 52 Cal.App.2d 217. A creditor can finish an execution sale, which severs the joint tenancy, or wait. If the other joint tenant dies first, the lien reaches the whole property. But “[i]f the judgment debtor is the first to die, the lien is lost.” (Grothe, at p. 1319.) The court called that rule “sound in theory and fair in its operation.” (Grothe, at p. 1324.)

The Result

The order granting the preliminary injunction was affirmed. The creditor could not sell the property to collect the judgment against Ribis.

What Grothe v. Cortlandt Corp. Means for California Co-Owners

  1. If your joint tenant died owing judgments, you may own the property free of them. A judgment lien or levy against only the deceased owner’s interest does not survive unless an execution sale was completed before the death.
  2. The rule cuts both ways. If you die first, your co-owner takes the whole property, and their creditors can then reach all of it. If you want your share to go to your heirs instead, you can sever the joint tenancy with a recorded deed under Civil Code section 683.2, as Riddle v. Harmon allows.
  3. Filing for partition does not sever by itself. Grothe notes that the “mere pendency of an action in partition does not sever a joint tenancy.” Only the judgment does. If you file as a joint tenant, record a severance deed too, and read what happens if your co-owner dies during a partition action.
  4. A lien on your co-owner’s share does not block a partition sale. Code of Civil Procedure section 873.820 pays liens from the sale proceeds, and a lien against only your co-owner comes out of their share, as Zieve v. Dhindsa confirms for loans. A creditor’s place in line is not permanent, though. In Starcevic v. Pentech, a creditor ranked first lost its lien and its place in line because it did not renew its judgment within 10 years. See our guides to selling a co-owned house with a lien and judgment liens on co-owned property.
  5. Tenants in common are treated differently. A tenancy in common has no right of survivorship, so a lien on a co-owner’s share stays on that share after the co-owner dies.

Your Co-Owner Has Judgments or Liens? Know Where You Stand

Grothe v. Cortlandt Corp. shows that how you hold title decides whether your co-owner’s debts follow the property. If your co-owner’s creditors are circling, or a lien has appeared on property you co-own, a partition attorney can tell you whether to sever the joint tenancy, sell, or both.

Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from the complaint through the referee’s sale and the final distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.

Related partition content

Categories: Joint Tenancy, Finance, Liens & Bankruptcy

Topics: , , , ,

Statutes: ,

Cases: , , , ,

Scott Talkov

About Scott Talkov

Scott Talkov founded Talkov Law, the first and largest law firm in the United States dedicated exclusively to partition actions. He oversees a team of 12 partition attorneys. He has handled more than 650 partition cases in 41 California counties, resolving over $400 million in co-owned real estate with zero partitions denied. He has been repeatedly selected to Super Lawyers, including the 2027 list.