Joint tenants often assume the right of survivorship is permanent: whoever lives longer takes the whole property. In McDonald v. Morley (1940) 15 Cal.2d 409, the California Supreme Court held that the joint tenants’ own agreement can end it. An agreement that each owner’s share will go to someone other than the survivor is inconsistent with a joint tenancy. It turns the owners into tenants in common, even if the same agreement says the property will “remain in Joint Tenancy.”
The daughter who inherited her mother’s half under a will kept it. Her father’s claim to the whole property as the surviving joint tenant failed.
Why McDonald v. Morley Matters
- It states the four unities. A joint tenancy “requires unity of interest, unity of title, unity of time, and unity of possession.” (McDonald, at p. 412.) Courts still quote this sentence, and Civil Code section 683 on how a joint tenancy is created builds the four unities into its text.
- Survivorship is what sets joint tenancy apart. The court called the right of survivorship “a distinguishing incident” of the estate. (McDonald, at p. 412.) It is the main difference between joint tenants and tenants in common.
- What the owners agreed to matters more than the label. Calling the property a joint tenancy did not save the right of survivorship once the owners agreed their shares would go elsewhere at death. The Supreme Court later applied the same idea to deeds in Machado v. Machado (1962) 58 Cal.2d 501: a joint tenancy deed can be overcome by the owners’ common understanding or agreement, but not by one owner’s hidden intentions.
- After a severance, each share can be inherited. The owners became “tenants in common with separate descendible interests,” so the mother’s half passed under her will. (McDonald, at p. 412.)
The Facts: A Divorce Agreement That Left the House to the Daughter
James and Evelyn McDonald held title to real property as joint tenants. Before their divorce, they signed a property settlement agreement. It said the property would “be and remain in Joint Tenancy, as it now stands, until such property can be sold” for at least $10,000, with the sale price divided equally. Until then, Evelyn could live on the property, run a school there and keep the income, and she would pay for repairs. Each of them would pay half of the loan interest, taxes, insurance and other carrying charges.
The agreement also said that if either of them died, “his or her share and interest therein shall become the property of their daughter, Helen K. Morley.” They promised to sign “a suitable legal instrument” to protect Helen. They never did, and the property was never sold.
Evelyn died, and her will left everything to Helen. James then sued his daughter to quiet title, claiming that as the surviving joint tenant he owned the whole property. The trial court found that the right of survivorship “was severed between the parties by agreement” and that each side owned half. James appealed to the California Supreme Court, which heard the case on its Los Angeles docket.
How the Supreme Court Decided the Case
An Agreement Inconsistent With Survivorship Ends the Joint Tenancy
James argued that because the agreement said the property would stay in joint tenancy until it was sold, nothing could sever the joint tenancy before a sale. The court looked at what the agreement actually did:
“But by their contract the parties specifically provided that if either one of them died, the interest of that one should not go to the survivor but to the daughter. This is entirely inconsistent with an estate in joint tenancy, which was thereby terminated.”
McDonald v. Morley (1940) 15 Cal.2d 409, 412
From the date of the agreement, the court held, “Mr. and Mrs. McDonald were tenants in common with separate descendible interests.” (McDonald, at p. 412.) A tenancy in common has no right of survivorship, so there was nothing for James to take when Evelyn died.
The Unsigned Paperwork Did Not Matter
James also argued that the promise to leave each share to Helen had no effect because the follow-up documents were never signed. That did not change the result. The agreement itself ended the joint tenancy, and the trial court found that Evelyn carried out her side by making a will in Helen’s favor.
The Result
The judgment was affirmed. Evelyn’s estate and James each owned an undivided one-half interest, each was entitled to half of the income after Evelyn’s death, and the carrying charges were split the same way. Helen took her mother’s half under the will.
What McDonald v. Morley Means for California Co-Owners
- Do not assume the survivor took everything. Without a severance, the survivor does take the whole property, as in Grothe v. Cortlandt Corp. (1992) 11 Cal.App.4th 1313. But if your parent or relative held title as a joint tenant and the other owner now claims the whole property, look for a divorce settlement, a co-ownership agreement or a recorded deed that severed the joint tenancy before the death.
- Today a severance has to be in writing. Civil Code section 683.2 on severing a joint tenancy lets one joint tenant sever alone by a recorded deed or written declaration, as in Riddle v. Harmon (1980) 102 Cal.App.3d 524, and it still recognizes a severance made by a written agreement of all the joint tenants. Spoken promises are a different matter: an oral agreement cannot prevent a severance.
- Co-owners can change survivorship without everyone. In Re v. Re (1995) 39 Cal.App.4th 91, two of three joint tenants cut off the third owner’s right of survivorship by deeding their shares to each other. A joint tenant who transfers their interest to anyone else ends survivorship for that share too.
- An heir who owns a share can force a sale. Once the joint tenancy is severed, the deceased owner’s share passes to their heirs, and an heir who inherits a share of real estate becomes a co-owner. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 872.210 (CCP 872.210 on who can file a partition action), any co-owner can file a partition action. If the surviving owner will not sell or buy you out, you can force the sale of jointly owned property.
- Finish the paperwork. The McDonalds never signed or recorded the documents their agreement called for, and the result was a lawsuit between a father and his daughter. A recorded deed to sever the joint tenancy removes the doubt.
Told the Surviving Owner Gets Everything? Check for a Severance First
McDonald v. Morley shows that the words “joint tenants” on a deed are not always the end of the story. If you inherited from a co-owner, or the other owner on title says your share disappeared when your family member died, have a partition attorney review the deed and every agreement the owners signed.
Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from the complaint through the referee’s sale and the final distribution of proceeds. No fees until you win. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.







