McCracken v. McCracken: Unmarried Co-Owners Can Force a Partition

In McCracken v. McCracken, the court held marriage is immaterial to partition: unmarried joint tenants on a "husband and wife" deed can force a sale.

McCracken v. McCracken: whether joint tenants were ever married is immaterial to the right to partition, even when the deed calls them husband and wife, so the court ordered the Los Angeles County lot sold

Unmarried couples who own a house together as joint tenants can each force a partition, even if the deed calls them “husband and wife.” In McCracken v. McCracken (1946) 75 Cal.App.2d 872, a man tried to stop his former partner’s partition by proving they had never married. The Court of Appeal held that whether they were married did not matter, and the Los Angeles County lot they owned was ordered sold.

Why McCracken v. McCracken Matters

  1. Marriage is not required to partition. Any co-owner on the deed may sue, whether the owners are married, dating, broken up or were never a couple at all.
  2. “Husband and wife” on a deed is just a description. The words do not change the joint tenancy or the right to partition.
  3. A co-owner’s claims need proof. The ex-partner said he paid for everything and the lot was meant to be his alone, but he offered no proof, and the court ordered a sale.
  4. A single lot is sold, not split. Because the lot could not be divided, the court ordered a partition by sale and an equal split of the money.

The Facts: A Couple on Title as “Husband and Wife”

In 1939, a grant deed conveyed a lot in Los Angeles County “to Roy McCracken and Irene A. McCracken, husband and wife as joint tenants.” The property was subject to a trust deed with $2,169.66 still owing. Irene later sued Roy for partition, alleging that each of them owned an undivided one-half interest. She asked the court to divide the lot or, if that could not be done fairly, to sell it, pay off the loan, and split the rest after costs and attorney’s fees.

Roy fought back on two fronts. He claimed he had made all the payments and that the lot was meant to be his sole and separate property. He also claimed that he and Irene had never been married, so the court had no power to partition the property at all.

The Trial: “It Doesn’t Matter Whether They Are Married”

At trial, Irene put the deed into evidence and rested. When Roy took the stand, his lawyer asked whether he had ever been married to Irene. The trial judge would not allow it:

“It doesn’t matter whether they are married or not. You and I could have a piece of property as joint tenants.”

Trial judge, quoted in McCracken v. McCracken (1946) 75 Cal.App.2d 872, 873

The judge explained that the property was deeded to two people as joint tenants, “and either one has a right therefore, to ask for a partition.” (McCracken, at p. 874.) Roy’s lawyer did not ask to amend Roy’s answer and made no offer of proof, meaning he never told the court what other evidence he had. The court found that the property was a single lot and that “it cannot be physicially divided” [sic], so it ordered the lot sold. (McCracken, at p. 874.) The loan was paid first, and after $100 in attorney’s fees and costs, the rest was divided equally. Roy appealed.

How the Court of Appeal Decided the Case

Being Unmarried Was “Immaterial”

The Court of Appeal affirmed. Roy’s answer admitted that the two had lived together without a marriage ceremony, but the court said that at most this meant the two were not married: “Whether they were or not was immaterial.” (McCracken, at p. 875.)

The court relied on McWhorter v. McWhorter (1929) 99 Cal.App. 293, where a deed ran to a man and “his wife” as joint tenants even though the woman was not his lawful wife. The McWhorter court held that the term “his wife” in the deed “was merely descriptive and surplusage,” so the deed was still a good conveyance to joint tenants. (McCracken, at p. 875.) The same was true of “husband and wife” on Roy and Irene’s deed.

A Fraud Claim Raised for the First Time on Appeal Went Nowhere

Roy’s new lawyer argued on appeal that Irene had gotten her interest through fraud. The court called this a “surprising passage” because nothing in Roy’s answer alleged fraud. A defense has to be pleaded and proved in the trial court; it cannot appear for the first time on appeal.

The Law Today

Today, Code of Civil Procedure section 872.710 provides that partition between co-owners “shall be as of right unless barred by a valid waiver.” Nothing in CCP 872.710’s right to partition or in CCP 872.210 on who can file a partition action depends on whether the co-owners are married. And when a house cannot be fairly split, CCP 872.820’s rule on ordering a sale lets the court sell it instead, which is what happens with almost every single-family home.

The deed still matters. A joint tenancy deed is strong evidence of equal ownership. In Gudelj v. Gudelj and Machado v. Machado, the California Supreme Court held that showing who paid, or one owner’s secret intent, is not enough to undo it. Co-owners can prove unequal shares when they agreed their shares would follow what each paid, as in Cosler v. Norwood and Kershman v. Kershman, but that takes real evidence, not just a claim in an answer. A co-owner who paid more can also ask for credits and reimbursements in the partition, such as for mortgage payments made after the breakup.

What McCracken v. McCracken Means for Unmarried Co-Owners

  1. You can force the sale after a breakup. If you and your ex-boyfriend or ex-girlfriend are both on the deed, you can force the sale of the house, even if your ex refuses to sell.
  2. “Husband and wife” on the vesting does not trap you. Check how title is held on your deed and your escrow vesting worksheet; descriptive words do not change your right to partition.
  3. Your ex can buy you out instead. A partition often ends in a buyout, but the case is what brings your ex to the table.
  4. Paid more? Ask for credits. If you paid the down payment or the mortgage and your ex wants half, the partition is where you claim those offsets.
  5. Want your ex off the deed? See how to get your ex off the deed in California.

Co-Own a House With Your Ex?

McCracken v. McCracken shows that a breakup does not leave you stuck with a co-owner. If your name is on the deed, the law gives you a way out through a partition action, ending in a referee’s sale or a buyout.

Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from filing the partition action through the sale and the final distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.

Related partition content

Categories: Joint Tenancy, Former Partners & Spouses

Topics: , , , ,

Statutes: , ,

Cases:

Scott Talkov

About Scott Talkov

Scott Talkov founded Talkov Law, the first and largest law firm in the United States dedicated exclusively to partition actions. He oversees a team of 12 partition attorneys. He has handled more than 650 partition cases in 43 California counties, resolving over $450 million in co-owned real estate with zero partitions denied. He has been repeatedly selected to Super Lawyers, including the 2027 list.