Filing a partition lawsuit does not end a joint tenancy in California. In Teutenberg v. Schiller (1955) 138 Cal.App.2d 18, a husband died while his wife’s partition case was still waiting for trial, and the Court of Appeal held that she took all of the property as the surviving joint tenant. In a partition, only a judgment entered while both joint tenants are alive ends the right of survivorship.
Why Teutenberg v. Schiller Matters
- A pending partition does not sever a joint tenancy. Until there is a judgment, the right of survivorship stays in place.
- A death before judgment changes everything. The survivor owns the whole property, and the estate of the joint tenant who died receives nothing.
- An agreement to delay trial is not a severance. Agreeing to postpone the case, and to share possession and rent in the meantime, left the joint tenancy as it was.
- Money from joint tenancy property stays joint. Proceeds keep their joint tenancy character unless the owners agree otherwise.
The Facts: A Partition Lawsuit, a One-Year Delay, and a Death
Ruby Teutenberg sued her husband, Frank, on August 15, 1952 in San Francisco to partition their home and several promissory notes secured by deeds of trust. All of it was held in joint tenancy, which is a form of co-ownership where the surviving owner takes the whole property when the other dies. All of it had been bought with Frank’s separate money, but paying more does not undo a joint tenancy deed. Frank answered that the deed and the notes had been obtained from him by fraud.
On November 21, 1952, Ruby and Frank signed a written agreement to postpone the partition trial for one year. Frank would move out, Ruby would live in the home rent-free, Frank would collect the rent from the upper flat and pay for upkeep, and the delay would not prejudice either side’s rights in the case.
Frank died 18 days after the year ran out, before any trial. Jerome Schiller, the special administrator of his estate, took his place in the lawsuit. Ruby then asked the court to award her everything as the surviving joint tenant under the right of survivorship.
The trial court agreed. It found that Ruby was the sole owner of the home and the notes and that Frank’s estate had no interest in them. It also awarded her the money Frank had collected on one of the notes during the lawsuit, which he had released by forging her signature. The estate appealed.
How the Court of Appeal Decided the Case
Only a Judgment Ends a Joint Tenancy in a Partition
The estate argued that Frank would have received at least half of the property at trial. The court agreed that this would have been true if Frank had lived until judgment. He did not:
“It is not the filing of the partition action which terminates the joint tenancy, but only the judgment in such action effects the termination, and then only when the action is tried during the lifetime of both the joint tenants.”
Teutenberg v. Schiller (1955) 138 Cal.App.2d 18, 22
The Agreement to Delay Trial Did Not Change the Result
The estate also argued that the one-year agreement fixed each side’s rights as of the day it was signed. Co-owners can sign a waiver of the right to partition, but this was not one. The court acknowledged that “the right to have partition is not absolute and may be waived by contract,” but found that “the agreement herein was not made to waive partition, but merely to continue a trial for partition for one year.” (Teutenberg, at p. 22.)
The agreement settled no property rights, said nothing about what would happen if one of them died, and had expired by its own terms. It also did not sever the joint tenancy. Under McDonald v. Morley (1940) 15 Cal.2d 409, joint tenants can end the right of survivorship by an agreement that is inconsistent with it. This agreement was not: “While an agreement inconsistent with the rules of survivorship under a joint tenancy will terminate such tenancy, the agreement herein contained no such provisions.” (Teutenberg, at p. 23.) An agreement about who lives in the property and who collects the rent is different: “Joint tenants may contract with each other for exclusive possession by one, or for part or all of the income without terminating such a tenancy.” (Teutenberg, at pp. 23-24.)
Money Collected on a Joint Tenancy Note Stayed Joint
The estate argued that once Frank collected one of the notes in full, there was nothing left for the court to award. The court disagreed. The money was the proceeds of joint tenancy property, and “[i]n the absence of any agreement to the contrary, proceeds of joint tenancy property retain the character of the property from which they are obtained.” (Teutenberg, at p. 24.) Ruby took that money as the survivor too. The judgment was affirmed.
The Law Today: Severing a Joint Tenancy Under Civil Code 683.2
A joint tenant does not have to wait for a partition judgment. Under Civil Code section 683.2, on severing a joint tenancy, one joint tenant can end the right of survivorship without the other’s consent. One way is to sign “a written declaration that, as to the interest of the joint tenant, the joint tenancy is severed.” Another is a deed from the joint tenant to herself. To cut off the other joint tenant’s survivorship rights, the document generally must be recorded before the joint tenant who signed it dies. In Re v. Re, though, two of three joint tenants who deeded their shares to each other cut off the third’s right of survivorship even though the deeds were not recorded until after one of them died. Our guide explains how to sever a joint tenancy in California.
The rule in Teutenberg still applies to the lawsuit itself. In Walters v. Boosinger (2016) 2 Cal.App.5th 421, a joint tenant filed for partition and died three months later. The Court of Appeal held that the partition complaint and the other owner’s answer did not sever the joint tenancy, so his estate had no interest left to partition.
What Teutenberg v. Schiller Means for California Co-Owners
- Do not rely on the lawsuit to protect your share. A joint tenant who wants their share to go to their own heirs should record a severance, not wait for the partition judgment.
- Severance cuts both ways. Ending the right of survivorship also gives up your own chance to take the whole property if the other owner dies first.
- Put it in writing if you agree to wait. An agreement to postpone a partition, like any agreement made after filing, should say what happens if one owner dies. If it says nothing, survivorship controls.
- A death during the case changes who the parties are. See what happens when a co-owner dies during a partition action.
Filing a Partition of Joint Tenancy Property?
Teutenberg v. Schiller shows what is at stake when a joint tenancy is left in place during a partition. A partition attorney can help you sever the joint tenancy, file the partition action, and move the case to judgment.
Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step, from the complaint through the referee’s sale and the final distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.








