One of the most common issues that arises in California real estate co-ownership disputes and related partition actions is the remedy for a party who pays more than their fractional share of the down payment.
For example, perhaps Sally and Joe purchase a home together, with Sally paying $100,000 of the down payment, while Joe pays $50,000 of the down payment. Does this mean that Sally owns 2/3rds of the house, and Joe owns 1/3rd of the house? As explained below, the law provides authority that Sally may be a 2/3rds owner in certain situations, while Sally may be a 1/2 owner entitled to reimbursement for her unequal down payment in other situations.
Does a Down Payment Reflect Ownership Percentages of a Partitioned Property?
Some authority suggests that a co-owner who pays more than their proportionate interest in acquisition holds an interest equivalent to their payment.
Miller & Starr, the leading treatise on California real estate, explains that: “As is the case with joint tenancy, a tenancy in common can exist in any interest in property, but contrary to the requirement in joint tenancy, the interests of cotenants need not be equal. Each tenant in common can own an interest in the property proportionate to his or her unequal contribution to the costs of acquisition.” [1]
When a deed creates a tenancy in common but does not state the cotenants’ shares, the law presumes equal interests. Caito v. United California Bank (1978) 20 Cal.3d 694, 705. Evidence of unequal down payments, the parties’ agreement, and other circumstances may establish that the stated or presumed ownership shares do not reflect the parties’ actual interests. See Cosler v. Norwood (1950) 97 Cal.App.2d 665, 666–667 (affirming unequal interests despite a joint-tenancy deed); Kershman v. Kershman (1961) 192 Cal.App.2d 23, 26–27 (considering the parties’ agreement and contributions); Demetris v. Demetris (1954) 125 Cal.App.2d 440, 442–445 (reforming a deed and allowing purchase-price reimbursement). But payment alone does not automatically change ownership: Donnelly v. Wetzel (1918) 37 Cal.App. 741, 742–743 divided partition sale proceeds according to established one-third and two-thirds interests while separately affirming a $600 personal judgment for a purchase-price advance. Our summary of Demetris v. Demetris walks through how the court reformed a joint tenancy deed and What does not change the shares is one owner’s private intent: in Machado v. Machado, the California Supreme Court held that a joint tenancy deed can be overcome only by evidence of a common understanding or agreement between the owners. And in Gudelj v. Gudelj (1953) 41 Cal.2d 202, 212, the court held that proof of who paid for the property is not enough by itself to overcome a joint tenancy deed.
Unequal Payments in a Joint Tenancy
While the unequal contributions may change ownership percentages in tenants in common, “Joint tenants hold their interests in the property in equal shares.” [2]
Indeed, California Civil Code 683(a) makes clear that: “A joint interest is one owned by two or more persons in equal shares…” [3]
As one court explained: “One of the characteristics of joint tenancy is the equality of the interest held by the respective tenants,” citing “Civ. Code § 683.” [4]
Unequal Payments in a Tenancy in Common
For example, one court held that, “as the parties held the property here in question as tenants in common, and as it is conceded that each party contributed equally to the acquisition thereof, upon the death of decedent,” the heir inherited an “undivided one-half interest standing in his name….” [5]
Indeed: “When two or more persons take as tenants in common under an instrument silent as to their respective shares, a presumption arises their shares are equal.” [6]
This is important since Summers v. Superior Court (2018) 24 Cal. App. 5th 138, 143 “conclude[d] that the trial court lacked the authority to order the sale of the property before it determined the parties’ respective ownership interests.”
However, parties can show that the property where the deed provides for joint tenancy or tenancy in common, or shows a differing ownership should be treated in another manner. Indeed, under Code of Civil Procedure section 872.820 (CCP 872.820), the proceeds of sale are divided according to the interests of the parties. However, to do this, they must meet the standard under California Evidence Code 662: “The owner of the legal title to property is presumed to be the owner of the full beneficial title. This presumption may be rebutted only by clear and convincing proof.”
Courts Occasionally Apply the Kershman Formula
In cases with clear evidence that ownership was intended to be contrary to record title, another theory may apply. In Kershman v. Kershman (1961) 192 Cal.App.2d 23, 27, “testimony amply support[ed] the implied finding that the plaintiff and defendant had agreed that their interests were not to be equal until defendant had paid his share, and that their interests were to represent at any given point of time the contemporaneous proportion of their respective contributions in relation to the total.”
Describing this case as having laid down the “Kershman formula,” another court found that “[m]any cases have held that where cotenants unequally contribute to the purchase price of real property, that a presumption arises that the cotenants intended to share in proportion to the amount contributed by each to the purchase price.” Sack v. Tomlin (1994) 110 Nev. 204, 210 (citing Kershman and Milian). A California court described this remedy from Kershman as a method to “determine the ownership interests in the property in proportion to the amounts contributed.” Milian v. De Leon (1986) 181 Cal.App.3d 1185, 1196.
Sack explained that: “In Kershman, the court described its approach to situations where cotenants contribute unequally to the purchase price of real property: ‘The proper approach would be to first determine the respective ownership interests of the parties whether equal or otherwise. Upon sale of the property there should be a determination of the share of each in the net proceeds according to those interests. Then any claims that one party may have against the other should be deducted from the share of the party to be charged and that of the other party should be increased accordingly.’” Sack v. Tomlin (1994) 110 Nev. 204, 211.
When co-owners are tenants in common, an owner who paid more than their agreed share of the purchase price may seek reimbursement through an accounting of the proceeds of sale in a California partition action, even where the ownership percentages themselves remain unchanged. Demetris v. Demetris (1954) 125 Cal.App.2d 440, 444–445; Donnelly v. Wetzel (1918) 37 Cal.App. 741, 742–743. In Milian v. De Leon (1986) 181 Cal.App.3d 1185, 1195–1196, the court discussed those authorities but expressly distinguished cases involving true joint tenants.
Milian explained that neither Demetris nor Donnelly established a right to reimbursement for unequal initial purchase-price contributions where the court finds a true joint tenancy. Under that form of ownership, the parties ordinarily have equal interests, subject to an enforceable agreement for reimbursement. Milian v. De Leon (1986) 181 Cal.App.3d 1185, 1195–1196.
For tenants in common, Demetris instead recognizes a claim for repayment when one cotenant advances more than their agreed share of the purchase price.[7]
Accordingly, an owner seeking reimbursement of an unequal down payment should establish both the nature of the co-ownership and the basis for repayment. A tenant in common may pursue reimbursement in the partition accounting after a partition sale, while a true joint tenant generally cannot obtain reimbursement merely because that owner paid more toward the initial purchase, absent an enforceable agreement.[8]
As partition lawyers, co-owners in the midst of a partition action often ask us how they can recover their fair share of an unequal down payment on a partitioned property. While some co-owners argue that the down payment should reflect the ownership percentages in the property contrary to the deed, the default rule is that they are equal owners.
Talkov Law's Partition Attorneys Can Help
If your co-owner won’t agree to sell or buy you out, a partition action ends the co-ownership for good. Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, Talkov Law is California’s #1 partition law firm. Our team handles every step of the process, from filing the partition action through the sale or buyout and the final division of the proceeds. Not a single court has denied our clients the right to partition.
Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online for a free consultation with a partition attorney.
References
| ↑1 | Creation and characteristics, 4 Cal. Real Est. (Miller & Starr, 4th ed.) § 11:34 (citing Schuyler v. Broughton (1886) 70 Cal. 282, 284; Estate of England (1991) 233 Cal.App. 3d 1, 4; Rupp v. Kahn (1966) 246 Cal.App. 2d 188, 196; Yeoman v. Sawyer (1950) 99 Cal. App. 2d 43, 46.) |
|---|---|
| ↑2 | Common law and statutory requisites of creation—Unity of interest, 4 Cal. Real Est. (Miller & Starr, 4th ed.) § 11:25. Miller & Starr explains that: “A joint tenancy in real property consists of an estate owned jointly in undivided equal shares by two or more persons. The ownership interest of joint tenants is regarded by law as constituting a fictitious unity. Each joint tenant is vested with title to an undivided equal share of the joint tenancy property, but this interest, being undivided, runs to the entire property.” Characteristics; creation, 4 Cal. Real Est. (Miller & Starr, 4th ed.) § 11:21 (citations omitted). |
| ↑3 | The full quote is that “A joint interest is one owned by two or more persons in equal shares, by a title created by a single will or transfer, when expressly declared in the will or transfer to be a joint tenancy, or by transfer from a sole owner to himself or herself and others, or from tenants in common or joint tenants to themselves or some of them, or to themselves or any of them and others, or from spouses, when holding title as community property or otherwise to themselves or to themselves and others or to one of them and to another or others, when expressly declared in the transfer to be a joint tenancy, or when granted or devised to executors or trustees as joint tenants. A joint tenancy in personal property may be created by a written transfer, instrument, or agreement.” Cal. Civ. Code § 683(a) |
| ↑4 | Stark v. Coker (1942) 20 Cal. 2d 839, 844 |
| ↑5 | Yeoman v. Sawyer (1950) 99 Cal. App. 2d 43, 46 |
| ↑6 | Caito v. United California Bank (1978) 20 Cal. 3d 694, 705 |
| ↑7 | Demetris v. Demetris (1954) 125 Cal.App.2d 440, 444–445; see also Finney v. Gomez (2003) 111 Cal.App.4th 527, 539, fn. 36. |
| ↑8 | Milian v. De Leon (1986) 181 Cal.App.3d 1185, 1195–1196. |








