In a California partition action, the co-owners share the costs of partition in proportion to their ownership interests, and those costs are usually paid out of the sale proceeds before the money is divided. The costs of partition include reasonable attorney’s fees spent for the common benefit, the partition referee’s fees, and other expenses of getting the property sold. A court can also make a co-owner who refuses to cooperate or drives up the cost pay more than an ownership share.
This question comes up most often when one co-owner wants to sell and the other refuses, whether the co-owners are siblings who inherited a house, former partners, or investors. The co-owner who files the partition action does the work that ends the co-ownership for everyone, and California law lets that co-owner ask the court to charge the other co-owners with their share of the cost.
What Is the Rule on Who Pays for a Partition Action?
The rule on who pays for a partition action comes from the California partition statutes. Code of Civil Procedure section 874.040 (CCP 874.040) provides:
Except as otherwise provided in this article, the court shall apportion the costs of partition among the parties in proportion to their interests or make such other apportionment as may be equitable.
CCP 874.040 on apportioning the costs of partition
“Section 874.040 has been consistently interpreted as giving courts only two options in apportioning the costs and fees of a partition action. The court may apportion the fees and costs based on the parties’ respective interests in the property, or it may apportion the costs and fees based on some other equitable apportionment.” Finney v. Gomez (2003) 111 Cal.App.4th 527, 545.
In practice, that means:
- The costs of partition start out split by ownership share. A co-owner who owns half of the property bears half of the shared costs, and a co-owner who owns one-quarter bears one-quarter.
- Only reasonable attorney’s fees spent for the common benefit of all the co-owners are shared.
- The court can order a different split when it would be fair, for example when one co-owner made the case harder or more expensive than it needed to be.
- Shared costs are normally paid from the sale proceeds before the remaining money is divided among the co-owners.
- There is no automatic “winner takes all” rule.
What Counts as a Cost of Partition?
Attorney’s fees are only one of the costs of partition. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 874.010 (CCP 874.010), the costs of partition include:
- “Reasonable attorney’s fees incurred or paid by a party for the common benefit.”
- The fee and expenses of the partition referee.
- The pay of a surveyor or other person the referee hires.
- The reasonable cost of a title report.
- Other expenses the court finds were incurred or paid for the common benefit.
See CCP 874.010 on what counts as costs of partition. The last category can reach court filing fees and the cost of getting the property ready for sale. The real estate broker’s commission is paid from the sale proceeds as an expense of the sale.
Who pays for the partition referee follows the same rule: the referee’s fee is a cost of partition, shared by ownership unless the court orders a different split.
Who Pays the Attorney’s Fees in a Partition Action?
In most lawsuits, each side pays its own lawyer. Partition is different. Because the case ends the co-ownership for everyone, reasonable attorney’s fees spent for the common benefit are a shared cost, and the starting point is a split by ownership.
In Finney v. Gomez (2003) 111 Cal.App.4th 527, 545, the Court of Appeal reversed an order charging all of the fees to one 50 percent owner and held that the fees should have been divided by the owners’ interests. Our summary of Finney v. Gomez covers the facts.
The same split applies even when a co-owner buys the property. In Stutz v. Davis (1981) 122 Cal.App.3d 1, 5, a one-third owner who forced the partition and then bought the property shared the attorney’s fees with the two-thirds owner by ownership. See how Stutz v. Davis split the fees.
Here is a simple example. Two siblings each own half of an inherited house. One sibling files a partition action, and the court finds that $30,000 of that sibling’s attorney’s fees were reasonable and for the common benefit. Each sibling bears $15,000. The sibling who paid the fees is repaid $15,000 out of the other sibling’s share of the sale proceeds.
Fee sharing is not limited to the co-owner who filed the case. Reasonable fees incurred for the common benefit by either side of a contested partition may be allocated among the co-owners. Orien v. Lutz (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 957, 966.
Which Attorney’s Fees Are “For the Common Benefit”?
Only attorney’s fees for the common benefit are shared. “[T]he ‘common benefit’ in a partition action is the proper distribution of the ‘respective shares and interests in said property by the ultimate judgment of the court.’” Orien v. Lutz (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 957, 967. In plain terms, the shared fees are the ones that move everyone toward a sale or division and a final split of the money.
Fees that usually qualify include filing and serving the partition complaint, obtaining the judgment ordering a sale, working with the partition referee, and getting the property sold. Fees aimed only at increasing one owner’s share at another’s expense may not qualify.
Your co-owner’s resistance does not turn the fees into your problem alone: “the presence of contested issues does not bar the allocation of fees in partition actions.” Orien v. Lutz (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 957, 968. The California Supreme Court reached the same result in Capuccio v. Caire (1932) 215 Cal. 518, 528–529, dividing a plaintiff’s common-benefit fees among all the owners even though the defendants had contested whether they were co-owners at all. Our summary of Capuccio v. Caire explains the decision.
Meritless positions are treated differently: “common benefit is not reasonably construed to include the pressing of spurious matters.” Forrest v. Elam (1979) 88 Cal.App.3d 164, 173. Our summary of Forrest v. Elam explains the decision.
Why 50/50 Co-Owners Often Skip the Fee Motion
When two co-owners each own half and both hired attorneys, each can ask the court to charge half of their common-benefit fees to the other. Often that is a wash. Say Bob files a partition against Sally, each spends $20,000 on attorney’s fees, and all of the fees are found to be for the common benefit. Bob could be awarded $10,000 of his fees from Sally’s share, while Sally could be awarded $10,000 of her fees from Bob’s share.
The net effect is that neither side collected anything from the other. A motion for fees would have cost money, extended the time to finish the case, and produced no net benefit to either co-owner. That is why many co-owners in this position accept a walk-away on the costs of partition, meaning a settlement or judgment that does not allocate fees or other costs to either side.
The math changes when the fees are not equal. A co-owner who did the work of filing the case and moving it to a sale, against a co-owner who never hired an attorney or never responded, has fees to share and nothing to offset them.
When the Court Makes One Co-Owner Pay More
CCP 874.040 allows the court to “make such other apportionment as may be equitable.” Courts use that power most often against a co-owner who wrongfully runs up the attorney’s fees, usually to delay the partition, and in favor of a co-owner with a small share who carried most of the cost of prosecuting the case.
The leading example is Lin v. Jeng (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 1008, 1025–1026. A sister claimed an 85 percent share of a family home even though she knew her siblings also owned interests, and she left them out of her complaint. The Court of Appeal upheld an order making her bear all of her own attorney’s fees, holding that “[t]he statute’s broad language does not limit the trial court’s equitable discretion.” See our summary of Lin v. Jeng.
“Sections 874.010 and 874.040 provide numerous avenues for trial courts to adjust the allocation of costs.” Orien v. Lutz (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 957, 968. A court can:
- Find that fees spent pressing a position of limited merit were not for the common benefit, so the co-owner who pressed that position bears them.
- Use its fairness power under CCP 874.040 to require a co-owner to bear its own fees.
- Reduce fees that were not reasonable.
The Law Revision Commission’s comment to CCP 874.040 gives two more examples:
Although normally the costs of partition are apportioned in proportion to the interests of the parties, there may be cases in which some other arrangement will be equitable. Where litigation for the common benefit arises among only some of the parties, or where the interest of the parties in all items, lots, or parcels of property are not identical, the court may segregate the costs of partition to the extent practicable and apportion a part among particular parties only.
Law Revision Commission comment to CCP 874.040, quoted in Finney v. Gomez (2003) 111 Cal.App.4th 527, 545–546
For cases under the Partition of Real Property Act, Code of Civil Procedure section 874.321.5 (CCP 874.321.5) lets the court charge the costs of partition to a co-owner who opposes the partition when doing so “is equitable and consistent with the purposes of this chapter.” A co-owner who intentionally frustrates the partition can be charged with the costs, including attorney’s fees. See CCP 874.321.5 on apportioning costs under the Partition of Real Property Act.
Can You Recover Your Attorney’s Fees From an Uncooperative Co-Owner?
Often, yes, at least in part. Recovery in a partition action usually means the court orders your co-owner’s share of the common-benefit fees to be repaid to you out of your co-owner’s share of the sale proceeds. Recovering more than that takes a record.
The trick is to document the non-cooperation. Before filing, put your offer to list the property for sale or to be bought out in writing, as in a letter warning of a partition action, and keep your co-owner’s refusals. Then give that record to the court, so its ruling can state why an unequal split is fair. When a partition action is filed only because a co-owner refused to cooperate in the same sale the court will order anyway, the court can charge that co-owner with the fees the refusal caused.
The Court of Appeal approved that result in an unpublished 2016 decision, upholding an order that placed the entire cost on a co-owner who “opposed the partition by sale”: “[t]he evidence presented at trial was more than sufficient to support the court’s decision to impose the cost burden entirely on appellant.” Cummings v. Cummings (Nov. 23, 2016, H040710) [nonpub. opn.].
The record matters because a court that departs from the ownership split needs evidence to support it. In Stutz v. Davis (1981) 122 Cal.App.3d 1, 5, the Court of Appeal split the fees by ownership because there was “nothing in the record” to support any other split.
Most Partitions Settle With Each Side Paying Its Own Fees
Attorneys might give you the false hope that your partition will be free by citing the laws on shifting attorney’s fees in a partition. The problem is that a shift beyond the ownership split occurs in a small number of heavily litigated cases.
What many attorneys won’t tell you, perhaps because they are unaware, is that most partitions end in a settlement. Those settlements involve either one co-owner, usually the defendant, buying out the other co-owner, or the property being listed for sale.
Co-owners are generally unwilling to pay the other side’s legal fees in a settlement, seeing this as an admission of wrongdoing. Most settlements have each side paying its own costs of partition. Prepare for that likely result by choosing an attorney who will litigate your partition efficiently.
A formal settlement offer under Code of Civil Procedure section 998 (CCP 998) adds pressure. A co-owner who rejects the offer and then fails to obtain a better result can be required to pay the costs incurred after the offer. Our post on 998 offers in partition actions explains how they work.
How the Costs of Partition Are Paid From the Sale Proceeds
Most co-owners never write a check to each other for fees. The costs come out of the money from the sale. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 873.820 (CCP 873.820), the proceeds are paid in this order:
- The expenses of the sale.
- The other costs of partition, including shared attorney’s fees.
- Liens on the property, such as mortgages, in order of priority.
- The rest, divided among the co-owners by their shares.
See CCP 873.820 on applying the sale proceeds. The court can also order costs paid before the final judgment under CCP 874.110 on when partition costs are paid. Costs charged to a co-owner become a lien on that co-owner’s share under CCP 874.120 on the lien for partition costs, and a judgment for unpaid costs can be enforced under CCP 874.140 on enforcing a judgment for unpaid costs.
This is why a co-owner can pursue a partition action even when cash is tight: the property itself usually pays the costs at the end.
How Much Does a Partition Action Cost?
Based on Talkov Law’s completed-case data, the average partition action costs about $20,000. The cost depends mostly on how hard your co-owner fights. A case where the co-owner agrees to sell or does not respond costs far less than a contested trial. At Talkov Law, there are no fees until you win. Our guide to the cost of a partition action in California covers what drives the cost up or down.
Keep Your Costs Low to Keep More of the Sale Proceeds
There’s nothing worse than a hollow victory where one co-owner is declared the winner, but the legal fees take away the benefit. Since most partitions settle with each side paying its own fees and costs, the surest way to raise your net recovery from the sale is to keep the cost of the case down. That means selecting an attorney who handles only partition law. At Talkov Law, we focus on efficient solutions to partition actions.
Talkov Law's Partition Attorneys Can Help
If your co-owner won’t agree to sell or buy you out, a partition action ends the co-ownership for good. Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, Talkov Law is California’s #1 partition law firm. Our team handles every step of the process, from filing the partition action through the sale or buyout and the final division of the proceeds. Not a single court has denied our clients the right to partition.
Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online for a free consultation with a partition attorney.








