California Code of Civil Procedure § 874.040 – Apportioning the Costs of Partition

CCP 874.040 has the court split partition costs, including attorney’s fees, by each co-owner’s share or in another way that is equitable.

CCP 874.040 Code of Civil Procedure, apportioning partition costs and attorney's fees, California: judge and attorneys review cost-allocation documents

California Code of Civil Procedure section 874.040 (CCP 874.040) tells the court how to split the costs of partition under CCP 874.010, including common-benefit attorney’s fees and referee fees: in proportion to the co-owners’ interests, or in another way that is equitable. It is one of the California partition statutes, and it applies whether the property is sold or divided.

Full Text of CCP 874.040

Except as otherwise provided in this article, the court shall apportion the costs of partition among the parties in proportion to their interests or make such other apportionment as may be equitable.

California Code of Civil Procedure section 874.040 (added by Statutes 1976, chapter 73)

What California Courts Say About Apportioning Partition Costs

As a leading California secondary source explains: “The fees must be apportioned among the parties in proportion to their interests, unless the court determines that some other apportionment is more equitable.” Partition Actions., 7 Witkin, Cal. Proc. 6th Judgm (2022) § 229.

“Again, the fact that the action was contested was no bar to the proportional allocation of attorney fees.” Orien v. Lutz (2017) 16 Cal.App.5th 957, 967.

In Finney v. Gomez (2003) 111 Cal.App.4th 527, 545–548, the Court of Appeal held that partition fees and costs are ordinarily divided by the owners’ interests, and that charging a 50 percent owner with all of them was an abuse of discretion because nothing in the record supported a different split.

“There is no ambiguity in the language of section 874.040. It simply states that the trial court must apportion the costs incurred in a partition action based upon either the parties’ interests in the property, or equitable considerations. The statute’s broad language does not limit the trial court’s equitable discretion, and we decline to follow Finney by doing so.” Lin v. Jeng (2012) 203 Cal.App.4th 1008, 1025. The court then upheld an order making a co-owner who claimed 85 percent of a family home, while knowing her siblings owned most of it, pay all of her own fees. (Id. at pp. 1025–1026.)

A related concept is that the court may award “reasonable attorney’s fees incurred or paid by a party for the common benefit.” California Code of Civil Procedure 874.010(a).

“The purpose of the statute is stated in Stewart v. Abernathy (1944) 62 Cal.App.2d 429 at p. 433, 144 P.2d 844 as follows: ‘… The purpose of the statute is to divide the cost of legal services among the parties benefited by the result of the proceeding.” Both appellant and respondent benefited from the proceedings and they should bear costs in accordance with their interest in the real property. Appellant, as two-thirds owner, should bear two-thirds of the cost and respondent, as one-third owner, should bear one-third of the costs.'” Stutz v. Davis (1981) 122 Cal.App.3d 1, 4–5.

One unpublished case noted the issue where a referee report allocated fees contrary to the interest of the parties as follows: “The referee’s accounting is irreconcilable with the general rule under section 874.040. The referee expressly allocated costs equally between the parties even though plaintiff’s and defendants’ interests are 85 percent and 15 percent, respectively. In order for the court to properly approve the referee’s accounting, therefore, the approval must be based on the final clause of the statute, which permits the trial court to ‘make such other apportionment as may be equitable.’ (§ 874.040.)” Akmakjian v. Haider (Cal. Ct. App., Dec. 3, 2010, No. E050146) 2010 WL 4913940, at *2.

How CCP 874.040 Works

Section 874.040 gives the court two choices. The default is to split the costs of partition by ownership: a 60 percent owner bears 60 percent. The court can instead order “such other apportionment as may be equitable.” The fact that the case was contested does not by itself change the default split, but a co-owner whose conduct made the partition more expensive can be ordered to bear more.

Our posts on Lin v. Jeng, where a co-owner who gamed a partition had to pay all of her own attorney’s fees, and Finney v. Gomez, where fees were split by ownership, show both sides of that choice. Our post on Orien v. Lutz explains why a contested case can still be for the common benefit.

Example: Splitting the Costs 60/40

Two co-owners hold a house in San Diego, 60 percent and 40 percent. The court finds $45,000 in costs of partition: $30,000 in common-benefit attorney’s fees, $12,000 for the referee, and $3,000 for the title report and other common expenses.

  • 60 percent owner’s share: $45,000 × 0.60 = $27,000
  • 40 percent owner’s share: $45,000 × 0.40 = $18,000
  • Check: $27,000 + $18,000 = $45,000

If the court finds that the 40 percent owner’s refusal to sell caused $10,000 of the fees, it can assign that $10,000 to the 40 percent owner and split the remaining $35,000 by ownership: $35,000 × 0.40 = $14,000, plus $10,000, for $24,000; and $35,000 × 0.60 = $21,000 for the 60 percent owner. See also who pays for a partition action.

The Law Revision Commission Comments on Section 874.040

The California Law Revision Commission drafted the partition statutes the Legislature enacted in 1976. Its comment on section 874.040 reads:

Section 874.040 supersedes the first portion of former Section 796. It applies the principle stated in the former section to cases where the property is sold as well as to those where it is divided. The general rule stated in Section 874.040 is qualified by Section 874.050.

Although normally the costs of partition are apportioned in proportion to the interests of the parties, there may be cases in which some other arrangement will be equitable. Where litigation for the common benefit arises among only some of the parties, or where the interests of the parties in all items, lots, or parcels of property are not identical, the court may segregate the costs of partition to the extent practicable and apportion a part among particular parties only. See former Section 796 (last sentence).

California Law Revision Commission Comment to Code of Civil Procedure section 874.040 (1976)

Common Questions About CCP 874.040

Will the Court Make My Co-Owner Pay All of My Attorney’s Fees?

Usually not all of them. The starting point is a split by ownership, so each co-owner bears a share of the common-benefit fees. The court can depart from that split when equity calls for it, for example when one co-owner’s conduct caused unnecessary expense, as in Lin v. Jeng. Our post on recovering partition attorney’s fees from an uncooperative co-owner explains how to build that record.

Does Fighting the Partition Change How Costs Are Split?

Not automatically. A contested case can still end with costs split by ownership, because under Orien v. Lutz fees spent resolving contested issues can still be for the common benefit. What matters is whether the expense was for the common benefit and whether another split is more equitable. A settlement offer under section 998 can also affect costs.

Where CCP 874.040 Fits in the California Partition Statutes

CCP 874.040 is part of Chapter 8 of the California partition statutes, which covers the costs of partition. Article 1 decides what counts as a cost and who bears it: 874.010 lists the costs of partition, 874.020 adds expenses from related cases that protect title, 874.030 allows interest on payments made at the court’s direction, section 874.040 apportions the costs among the co-owners, and 874.050 deals with the share charged to a future interest.

Article 2 covers payment. Under 874.110 the court can order costs paid before judgment and must list any unpaid costs in the judgment, 874.120 makes those costs a lien with top priority on the responsible co-owner’s share, 874.130 allows a sale to pay cost liens, and 874.140 lets the person owed the costs enforce the judgment. When the property is sold, CCP 873.820 pays the costs of partition from the sale proceeds before the co-owners receive their shares.

Talkov Law Partition Attorneys Can Help

How the court splits the costs can change each co-owner’s net recovery by thousands of dollars. Presenting the fees and the reasons for the split clearly is part of getting the best result. Our post on what a partition action costs covers typical numbers, and our post on allocation of costs under the Partition of Real Property Act covers property governed by that act.

Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step of the process, from the complaint and the court-ordered sale through the final accounting and the distribution of proceeds. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online to get started.

Related partition content

Categories: Attorney's Fees & Costs

Topics:

Statutes: , ,

Cases: , , , ,

Scott Talkov

About Scott Talkov

Scott Talkov founded Talkov Law, the first and largest law firm in the United States dedicated exclusively to partition actions. He oversees a team of 12 partition attorneys. He has handled more than 650 partition cases in 41 California counties, resolving over $400 million in co-owned real estate with zero partitions denied. He has been repeatedly selected to Super Lawyers, including the 2027 list.