CCP 430.41: Meet and Confer Before a Demurrer in a California Partition Action

CCP 430.41 requires a meet and confer before any California demurrer. How the rule works in a partition action, and what a partition complaint must allege.

CCP 430.41 meet and confer before a demurrer, Code of Civil Procedure, California partition: two attorneys review a meet-and-confer folder

Before a party in a California lawsuit can file a demurrer, Code of Civil Procedure section 430.41 requires it to meet and confer with the other side, in person, by telephone, or by video conference, to see whether the objections can be resolved without a hearing. The rule took effect on January 1, 2016, through Senate Bill 383. It was first set to expire on January 1, 2021, but the current statute has no expiration date, so it is a permanent part of California civil procedure.

The rule applies in a partition action just as it does in any other civil case, because the ordinary rules of civil procedure govern a partition unless a partition statute says otherwise (Code of Civil Procedure section 872.030). For a co-owner who files to force a sale, section 430.41 works in your favor: a co-owner who wants to attack the complaint must first explain the objection, and a complaint that pleads what the partition statutes require leaves little to object to.

What a Partition Complaint Must Allege

A demurrer argues that a complaint, cross-complaint, or answer fails to state a valid claim or defense, or is otherwise defective. A partition complaint is hard to attack this way because the statutes spell out what it must contain. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 872.230, the complaint must set out:

  1. A description of the property. For real property, its legal description and its street address or common designation, if it has one.
  2. The plaintiff’s interest. Every interest the plaintiff has or claims in the property.
  3. Everyone else’s interests. The interests that others have or claim, of record or known to the plaintiff, that the plaintiff reasonably believes the case will materially affect, whether or not their names are known.
  4. The estate to be partitioned. The estate for which partition is sought, and a request for partition of the interests in it.
  5. Facts supporting a sale, if a sale is requested. When the plaintiff asks the court to sell the property rather than divide it, the facts that justify a sale, stated in ordinary and concise language.

The right to file comes from Code of Civil Procedure section 872.210, which lets a co-owner bring the action, and under Code of Civil Procedure section 872.710, subdivision (b), the court must order partition unless the right has been waived. That is why the right to partition is called absolute. The complaint also does not have to say how the property should be divided. In De Uprey v. De Uprey (1865) 27 Cal. 329, 331, the California Supreme Court held that “the manner in which the partition is to be made constitutes no part of the cause of action, but is merely a part of the relief.” Our sample partition complaint shows how each of these elements is pleaded.

How Section 430.41 Works

Section 430.41 has seven parts that matter in practice, whether you are defending your partition complaint or challenging the other side’s answer.

1. Meet and Confer Before Any Demurrer, Including to an Amended Pleading

Subdivision (a) requires the parties to meet and confer, in person, by telephone, or by video conference, before a demurrer is filed, “for the purpose of determining whether an agreement can be reached that would resolve the objections to be raised in the demurrer.” This same subsection also imposes a further “meet and confer again with the party who filed the amended pleading before filing a demurrer to the amended pleading.”

2. What the Meet and Confer Must Cover

Subdivision (a)(1) specifies the content of the meet and confer process, explaining that “the demurring party shall identify all of the specific causes of action that it believes are subject to demurrer and identify with legal support the basis of the deficiencies. The party who filed the complaint, cross-complaint, or answer shall provide legal support for its position that the pleading is legally sufficient or, in the alternative, how the complaint, cross-complaint, or answer could be amended to cure any legal insufficiency.” For a partition plaintiff, this is the time to answer with the statute: a complaint that pleads each element of section 872.230 is legally sufficient, and a small fix can be offered as an amendment instead of being argued at a hearing.

3. Automatic 30-Day Extension When the Parties Cannot Meet and Confer

Subdivision (a)(2) provides: “The parties shall meet and confer at least five days before the date the responsive pleading is due. If the parties are not able to meet and confer at least five days prior to the date the responsive pleading is due, the demurring party shall be granted an automatic 30-day extension of time within which to file a responsive pleading, by filing and serving, on or before the date on which a demurrer would be due, a declaration stating under penalty of perjury that a good faith attempt to meet and confer was made and explaining the reasons why the parties could not meet and confer. The 30-day extension shall commence from the date the responsive pleading was previously due, and the demurring party shall not be subject to default during the period of the extension. Any further extensions shall be obtained by court order upon a showing of good cause.”

In a partition action, that cuts against a plaintiff who ignores the defense lawyer’s call or email. A missed meet and confer gives the defendant an automatic 30 extra days to respond, so a plaintiff who wants the case to move should return the call promptly and confirm the meet and confer in writing.

4. A Meet and Confer Declaration Must Accompany Every Demurrer

Subdivision (a)(3) requires: “The demurring party shall file and serve with the demurrer a declaration stating either of the following: (A)  The means by which the demurring party met and conferred with the party who filed the pleading subject to demurrer, and that the parties did not reach an agreement resolving the objections raised in the demurrer. (B)  That the party who filed the pleading subject to demurrer failed to respond to the meet and confer request of the demurring party or otherwise failed to meet and confer in good faith.”

The statute gives no specific remedy for an insufficient meet and confer. Instead, it provides that “[a]ny determination by the court that the meet and confer process was insufficient shall not be grounds to overrule or sustain a demurrer.” (Subdivision (a)(4).) A thin meet and confer will not, by itself, win or lose the demurrer.

5. No Second Demurrer on Grounds That Could Have Been Raised the First Time

Subdivision (b) eliminates the ability of counsel to repeatedly demur to portions of a pleading that remain unchanged. Specifically, it provides that: “A party demurring to a pleading that has been amended after a demurrer to an earlier version of the pleading was sustained shall not demur to any portion of the amended complaint, cross-complaint, or answer on grounds that could have been raised by demurrer to the earlier version of the complaint, cross-complaint, or answer.”

In practice, a defendant gets one round of objections to allegations that stay the same. If a partition plaintiff amends to fix one problem, the defendant cannot use the next demurrer to raise new objections to parts of the complaint it already had the chance to attack.

6. Court-Ordered Conferences After a Demurrer Is Sustained

Subdivision (c) allows the court to order a conference after it sustains a demurrer with leave to amend, to head off another round of demurrers. It provides: “If a court sustains a demurrer to one or more causes of action and grants leave to amend, the court may order a conference of the parties before an amended complaint or cross-complaint or a demurrer to an amended complaint or cross-complaint, may be filed. If a conference is held, the court shall not preclude a party from filing a demurrer and the time to file a demurrer shall not begin until after the conference has concluded. Nothing in this section prohibits the court from ordering a conference on its own motion at any time or prevents a party from requesting that the court order a conference to be held.”

Courts tend to use this in hotly contested cases, where another round of demurrers would only add delay.

7. A Three-Amendment Limit, With Four Exceptions

Subdivision (e) limits how many times a pleading can be amended in response to demurrers. Subdivision (e)(1) provides: “In response to a demurrer and prior to the case being at issue, a complaint or cross-complaint shall not be amended more than three times . . . .”

The statute builds four exceptions into this limit.

The first exception is in subdivision (e)(1), which provides that the three-strikes rule is only for amendments: “In response to a demurrer and prior to the case being at issue . . . .” In other words, the three strikes appears to apply only to amendments after a demurrer is sustained, not to amendments made after a meet and confer.

The second exception, also in subdivision (e)(1), is that the limit applies only “absent an offer to the trial court as to such additional facts to be pleaded that there is a reasonable possibility the defect can be cured to state a cause of action.” In other words, the longstanding practice of courts to allow amendments if an amendment can cure the defect remains.

The third exception, also in subdivision (e)(1), provides: “The three-amendment limit shall not include an amendment made without leave of the court pursuant to Section 472, provided the amendment is made before a demurrer to the original complaint or cross-complaint is filed.” Under Code of Civil Procedure section 472, a party may amend its pleading once without leave of court, either before an answer, demurrer, or motion to strike is filed, or after one is filed but before the hearing, as long as the amended pleading is filed and served by the deadline for opposing it. Amendments on the eve of the hearing are not allowed.

The fourth exception is in subdivision (e)(2): “Nothing in this section affects the rights of a party to amend its pleading or respond to an amended pleading after the case is at issue.”

Section 430.41 in a Partition Action

For a co-owner who files to force a sale, four points matter most:

  1. Plead every element of section 872.230. A complaint that describes the property, states each party’s interest, requests partition, and alleges the facts supporting a sale gives a defendant little to demur to. When a meet and confer request arrives, answer it with the statute.
  2. Ownership disputes are not grounds to throw out the complaint. Disagreements over who owns what share are decided inside the partition under Code of Civil Procedure section 872.610. A plaintiff who is mistaken about the other owners’ shares still gets a partition, as De Uprey held.
  3. Section 430.41 cuts both ways. A plaintiff can demur to a defendant’s answer, for example one that pleads boilerplate affirmative defenses, and must meet and confer first in the same way.
  4. Return the call. Skipping the meet and confer only gives the defendant an automatic 30-day extension.

A demurrer that is overruled sends the defendant back to file an answer to the partition complaint, and the case moves toward an interlocutory judgment ordering the sale.

Full Text of Code of Civil Procedure Section 430.41

The current text of the statute, as published on the Legislature’s official website:

(a)  Before filing a demurrer pursuant to this chapter, the demurring party shall meet and confer in person, by telephone, or by video conference with the party who filed the pleading that is subject to demurrer for the purpose of determining whether an agreement can be reached that would resolve the objections to be raised in the demurrer. If an amended complaint, cross-complaint, or answer is filed, the responding party shall meet and confer again with the party who filed the amended pleading before filing a demurrer to the amended pleading.

(1)  As part of the meet and confer process, the demurring party shall identify all of the specific causes of action that it believes are subject to demurrer and identify with legal support the basis of the deficiencies. The party who filed the complaint, cross-complaint, or answer shall provide legal support for its position that the pleading is legally sufficient or, in the alternative, how the complaint, cross-complaint, or answer could be amended to cure any legal insufficiency.
(2)  The parties shall meet and confer at least five days before the date the responsive pleading is due. If the parties are not able to meet and confer at least five days prior to the date the responsive pleading is due, the demurring party shall be granted an automatic 30-day extension of time within which to file a responsive pleading, by filing and serving, on or before the date on which a demurrer would be due, a declaration stating under penalty of perjury that a good faith attempt to meet and confer was made and explaining the reasons why the parties could not meet and confer. The 30-day extension shall commence from the date the responsive pleading was previously due, and the demurring party shall not be subject to default during the period of the extension. Any further extensions shall be obtained by court order upon a showing of good cause.
(3)  The demurring party shall file and serve with the demurrer a declaration stating either of the following:
(A)  The means by which the demurring party met and conferred with the party who filed the pleading subject to demurrer, and that the parties did not reach an agreement resolving the objections raised in the demurrer.
(B)  That the party who filed the pleading subject to demurrer failed to respond to the meet and confer request of the demurring party or otherwise failed to meet and confer in good faith.

(4)  Any determination by the court that the meet and confer process was insufficient shall not be grounds to overrule or sustain a demurrer.

(b)  A party demurring to a pleading that has been amended after a demurrer to an earlier version of the pleading was sustained shall not demur to any portion of the amended complaint, cross-complaint, or answer on grounds that could have been raised by demurrer to the earlier version of the complaint, cross-complaint, or answer.
(c)  If a court sustains a demurrer to one or more causes of action and grants leave to amend, the court may order a conference of the parties before an amended complaint or cross-complaint or a demurrer to an amended complaint or cross-complaint, may be filed. If a conference is held, the court shall not preclude a party from filing a demurrer and the time to file a demurrer shall not begin until after the conference has concluded. Nothing in this section prohibits the court from ordering a conference on its own motion at any time or prevents a party from requesting that the court order a conference to be held.
(d)  This section does not apply to the following civil actions:   (1)  An action in which a party not represented by counsel is incarcerated in a local, state, or federal correctional institution.
(2)  A proceeding in forcible entry, forcible detainer, or unlawful detainer.

(e)   (1)  In response to a demurrer and prior to the case being at issue, a complaint or cross-complaint shall not be amended more than three times, absent an offer to the trial court as to such additional facts to be pleaded that there is a reasonable possibility the defect can be cured to state a cause of action. The three-amendment limit shall not include an amendment made without leave of the court pursuant to Section 472, provided the amendment is made before a demurrer to the original complaint or cross-complaint is filed.
(2)  Nothing in this section affects the rights of a party to amend its pleading or respond to an amended pleading after the case is at issue.

(f)  Nothing in this section affects appellate review or the rights of a party pursuant to Section 430.80.
(g)  If a demurrer is overruled as to a cause of action and that cause of action is not further amended, the demurring party preserves its right to appeal after final judgment without filing a further demurrer.

Talk to a Partition Attorney

A partition complaint drafted right the first time keeps the case moving toward a sale, even against a co-owner who contests every step. Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, including Los Angeles, Orange County, San Diego, Riverside, Sacramento, San Francisco, and San Jose, we handle every step, from drafting the complaint through the sale. No fees until you win. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) or contact us online for a free 30-minute consultation.

Related partition content

Categories: Discovery & Trial

Statutes: ,

Scott Talkov

About Scott Talkov

Scott Talkov founded Talkov Law, the first and largest law firm in the United States dedicated exclusively to partition actions. He oversees a team of 12 partition attorneys. He has handled more than 650 partition cases in 41 California counties, resolving over $400 million in co-owned real estate with zero partitions denied. He has been repeatedly selected to Super Lawyers, including the 2027 list.