Anti-Heart Balm Statute in California Partition Actions

What is the anti-heart balm statute in California?

California’s anti-heart balm statute is a state law that prevents someone from suing their former romantic partner over a broken promise (or promises) that was to be met on the condition of marriage or during the course of the marriage. These statutes arose due to the common law tradition that allowed damages to be recovered against a former romantic partner over a broken promise related to becoming married. Most states have these heartbalm statutes to prevent unnecessary litigation surrounding damages from a break up alleging a promise to become married or benefits during the marriage.

Does California have an anti-heart balm statute?

A fraudulent promise to marry or to cohabit after marriage does not give rise to a cause of action for damages.” Civ. Code § 43.4. In fact: “No cause of action arises for: (a) Alienation of affection…. (c) Seduction of a person over the age of legal consent. (d) Breach of promise of marriage.” Civ. Code § 43.5. This anti-heart balm statute was enacted by California as a matter of public policy to prevent costly litigation stemming from a broken heart. “The California anti-heart-balm statutes, which long ago did away with breach of promise actions, establish a public policy against litigation of the affairs of the heart.” Askew v. Askew (1994) 22 Cal.App.4th 942, 947, as modified on denial of reh’g (Mar. 14, 1994). Furthermore, “Section 43.5 is designed to eliminate a class of lawsuits…which promoted fraud and perjury and encouraged marriages motivated by fear of a lawsuit instead of love.” Boyd v. Boyd (1964) 228 Cal. App. 2d 374, 377–78.

“Sometimes referred to as the ‘anti-heart-balm statute,’ section 43.5 ‘was enacted to eliminate a class of lawsuits which were often fruitful sources of fraud and extortion and easy methods to embarrass, harass, and besmirch the reputation of one wholly innocent of wrongdoing. The statute creates a blanket immunization from liability for the conduct it protects unless such conduct ‘breaches a duty of care independent of the causes of action barred therein.’” Richelle L. v. Roman Cath. Archbishop (2003) 106 Cal.App. 4th 257, 266–67, as modified (Mar. 17, 2003).

Partition actions involving the anti-heart balm statute

It’s not uncommon for modern engaged couples to purchase a home together in anticipation of marriage. If the relationship goes south and they decide to break up, how will the home be split? Because the couple is not yet legally married, the family attorneys do not have jurisdiction to file an action in family court over the home as they would in a divorce.

Instead, the property can be equitably divided in civil court through a partition action. The seasoned partition attorneys at Talkov Law have seen ex-partners file meritless cross-complaints when faced with partition actions given that there are few defenses to a partition action. Among these cross-complaints can include attempts to collect damages based on a broken heart alone, but California’s anti-heart balm statute makes it so that heartbroken individual cannot sue their former romantic partner for damages. Simply promising to marry another is insufficient for receiving damages or partition offsets in a partition action or otherwise.

Talkov Law's Partition Attorneys Can Help

If you want to end your co-ownership relationship, but your co-owner won’t agree, a partition action is your only option. With seven, full time partition lawyers, Talkov Law is the #1 partition law firm in California and has handled over 300 partition actions throughout California. Every case has resulted in a sale to either a third party or one of the co-owners. Not a single court has denied our clients the right to partition or declared our client to be a non-owner. Plus, for qualified cases, there is no fee until we settle or win your case!

If you're looking to end your co-ownership dispute, contact California's premier partition action law firm by calling Talkov Law at (844) 4-TALKOV (825568) or sending us a message today.

Avatar photo
About Talkov Law Partition Attorneys

The partition attorneys at Talkov Law end co-ownership disputes by representing co-owners in real estate partition actions throughout the State of California.

Talkov Law is Rated 5 out of 5 stars based on 103 customer reviews.

Contact Us Today for a Free Consultation & Pay No Retainer

Call Talkov Law to discuss having your legal fees paid from the proceeds of sale of your property and no money down

      Awards and Recognition

      US News and World Report Scott Talkov

      We Have Been Featured On:

      The Real Deal

      Offices Throughout California

      Los Angeles Office
      10880 Wilshire Blvd Ste 1101
      Los Angeles, CA 90024
      Phone: (310) 496-3300

      Orange County Office
      4000 MacArthur Blvd Ste 655
      Newport Beach, CA 92660
      Phone: (949) 888-8800

      San Jose Office
      99 S. Almaden Blvd Suite 600
      San Jose, CA 95113
      Phone: (408) 777-6800

      San Diego Office
      11622 El Camino Real Ste 100
      San Diego, CA 92130
      Phone: (858) 800-3300

      San Francisco Office
      50 California St, Ste 1500
      San Francisco, CA 94111
      Phone: (415) 966-3300

      Riverside Office
      3610 Central Ave, Ste 400
      Riverside, CA 92506
      Phone: (951) 888-3300

      Sacramento Office
      500 Capitol Mall, Suite 2350
      Sacramento, CA 95814
      Phone: (916) 668-3300

      The information on this site, including the Talkov Law Blog, is intended for general information purposes only. By using this site, you agree that any information contained in the site does not constitute legal, financial or any other form of professional advice. Information on this site may be changed without notice and is not guaranteed to be complete, accurate, correct or up-to-date.