Is There a Statute of Limitations on a Partition Action?

Is there a deadline to file a partition action in California? Learn whether a statute of limitations applies, even when a co-owner left years ago.

Is There a Statute of Limitations on a Partition Action? — Talkov Law illustration

No. There is no statute of limitations on a partition action in California. As the California Supreme Court held in Adams v. Hopkins (1904) 144 Cal. 19, 27, “The statute of limitations never bars relief between tenants in common in an action of partition.” The one exception is a co-owner who has already lost title altogether, because another owner held the property openly and hostilely against them long enough to take it by adverse possession. As long as you are still a co-owner, you can file a partition action at any time.

This question usually comes from a co-owner who moved out years ago. Perhaps a brother has lived in your late mother’s house for 15 years, or an ex stayed in the home you bought together and has paid the property taxes ever since. Moving out, and even not paying the bills, does not end your ownership or your right to force a sale. It can change how the money is divided, which is covered below. Our summary of Martin v. Walker explains why a co-owner out of possession can still sue for partition.

The Right to Partition Is Absolute, So Time Does Not Bar It

A statute of limitations is a deadline to file a particular kind of lawsuit. Partition has none, because the right to partition is absolute. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 872.710 (CCP 872.710), partition of concurrent interests is a matter of right unless a valid waiver bars it. As one Court of Appeal put it, “if the party seeking partition is shown to be a tenant in common, and as such entitled to the possession of the land sought to be partitioned, the right is absolute.” (Bacon v. Wahrhaftig (1950) 97 Cal.App.2d 599, 603.) Miller & Starr, the leading treatise on California real estate, likewise describes each cotenant’s right to partition as “absolute.” (4 Miller & Starr, Cal. Real Estate (4th ed.) § 11:14.)

The Supreme Court tied the two ideas together in Adams:

“The statute of limitations never bars relief between tenants in common in an action of partition.”

Adams v. Hopkins (1904) 144 Cal. 19, 27

In plain terms, the right to partition exists for as long as the co-ownership exists. Our summary of Adams v. Hopkins covers the facts of the case and how the court treated the parties who had lost land by adverse possession. Courts still apply Adams today; in an unpublished 2014 opinion, the Court of Appeal quoted it for the rule that, because the right is absolute, time does not bar a partition claim.[1]

The One Exception: A Co-Owner Who Has Already Lost Title

Time matters only when it has already cost a co-owner the title itself. The Adams court explained that the statute of limitations runs against a partition claim only when the co-owner has lost all rights in the property and those rights have vested in someone else. That happens through adverse possession, and adverse possession against a co-owner is hard to prove.

Every co-owner has the right to possess the whole property, so a co-owner living there alone is presumed to be there with everyone’s permission. As the Supreme Court explained, “exclusive occupancy by a cotenant is deemed permissive; it does not become adverse until the tenant out of possession has had either actual or constructive notice that the possession of the cotenant is hostile to him.”[2] Living in the house, collecting the rent, or paying the bills is not enough. The co-owner in possession must make it clear that they claim the whole property for themselves, which is an ouster, and then hold it for the full adverse-possession period, which in California is five years and requires paying the property taxes (Code of Civil Procedure section 325 (CCP 325)).

Say your sister changed the locks, told you in writing that the house is hers alone, and has paid every tax bill since. Each year that passes brings her closer to a claim that your interest is gone. That is the real reason not to wait: not a filing deadline, but the risk that the other owner builds an adverse possession case while you do nothing. Our article on whether someone can move into your jointly owned home without your permission covers adverse possession between co-owners in more detail.

Moving Out Doesn’t End Your Ownership, but It Affects the Accounting

Expect the co-owner who stayed to argue that your share should shrink because you paid nothing toward the mortgage, property taxes, insurance, or repairs. Those claims belong in the offsets and accounting at the end of the case, not in a fight over whether you can file. Under Code of Civil Procedure section 872.140 (CCP 872.140), the court can credit the owner who paid those costs.

Those credits can be reduced, too. In Hunter v. Schultz (1966) 240 Cal.App.2d 24, 30–32, the court upheld an offset for the value of the occupying co-owners’ use of the property against their claims for mortgage interest, taxes, and insurance. That does not mean every co-owner who lives in the property automatically owes rent, but when the co-owner in possession asks to be repaid for years of expenses, the rental value of their possession often comes close to cancelling out the claim. Our article on a co-owner not paying property taxes explains how tax payments are credited.

Don’t Wait Out a Co-Owner Who Won’t Sell

No statute of limitations bars your partition action, but delay still costs you: in market risk, in mounting credits for the co-owner in possession, and, in the worst case, in a claim that you lost title altogether. Our guide to how long a partition action takes explains what waiting to file adds.

Talkov Law can help. With 12 full-time partition attorneys and experience in over 650 partition actions throughout California, our team handles every step of the process, from confirming that your ownership is intact through the referee’s sale and the final accounting of who paid what. Call (877) PARTITION (727-8484) today or contact us online for a free consultation with a partition attorney.

References

References
↑1 Kaut v. Kelsey (Feb. 7, 2014, A136094) 2014 WL 495497, at *4 [nonpub. opn.], quoting Adams v. Hopkins (1904) 144 Cal. 19, 27.
↑2 West v. Evans (1946) 29 Cal.2d 414, 418.
Related partition content

Categories: Right to Partition, Defenses to Partition

Topics: , ,

Statutes: , ,

Cases: , , , ,

Scott Talkov

About Scott Talkov

Scott Talkov founded Talkov Law, the first and largest law firm in the United States dedicated exclusively to partition actions. He oversees a team of 12 partition attorneys. He has handled more than 650 partition cases in 41 California counties, resolving over $400 million in co-owned real estate with zero partitions denied. He has been repeatedly selected to Super Lawyers, including the 2027 list.